Dear colleagues!
Just a few thoughts. I have
- 7 x IPv4 /22 PA
- 1 x IPv4 /24 PA
- 4 ASNs
which is equivalent to 29 x IPv4 /24. Therefore I am not a very small LIR, but between small and medium sized. As very small LIR I would consider a LIR with less than a IPv4 /22 equivalent.
With Option B, the Category Model, I will pay €2,567.
With Option A, the One LIR Account-One Fee Model, I will pay €2,044.
Before redistribution: In 2022 I paid €1,400. In 2023 I paid €1,550. In 2025 I paid €2,000.
In three years, the fees raised by 43% (2022-2025). If option B is selected, the fees raised totally by 83% in five years (2022-2027).
Even if option A is selected, we have a total change of 46% in five years (2022-2027).
While it is my opinion, that a very small LIR should pay less than me, the main concern here is that the costs of the RIPE NCC are just too high:
How much shall I pay after the 2027-2031 period? Will I pay €5,000 then in 2032? Will very small LIRs then also pay €1,700 or so, so that the change (which first looked good for them) was useless, especially since it is likely that they received resources in the meantime?
The RIPE NCC may still forget that this may cause many LIRs to sell their resources to large companies.
Thanks for your time.
--Kayo
