** *Dear Kaj, * * Thank you for bearing with us. We can now provide a few more details. We recommend watching Sjoerd’s recent presentation on the infrastructure renewal project at RIPE 93, which should provide some additional clarity on why we are doing this project and what is involved: https://ripe93.ripe.net/programme/meeting-plan/sessions/148/SNSVJF/ <https://ripe93.ripe.net/programme/meeting-plan/sessions/148/SNSVJF/> The presentation from Hans Petter in the same session on the Draft Activity Plan and Budget also has some relevant information and reasoning: https://ripe93.ripe.net/programme/meeting-plan/sessions/148/HFKVUM/ <https://ripe93.ripe.net/programme/meeting-plan/sessions/148/HFKVUM/> INCOME AND COSTS When talking about the need to increase our income, this is primarily about keeping pace with inflation. The estimated 3-5% increase in annual income in my earlier mail reflects the degree of economic uncertainty we are facing. For comparison, Dutch consumer prices increased by something on the order of 25% over the five years from 2020-2025 [1]. Our current modelling is based on a 3% increase, but we see several areas where costs are increasing more than that, so further increases may be needed. As already mentioned, there are other ways we can approach income that have been suggested by the Charging Scheme Task Force, so this does not necessarily have to result in a corresponding increase in the base membership fee.
Your reply projects additional annual opex of 1.4M eur from 2028, excluding depreciation, while identifying [cloud] savings of more than 100k annually. It is not clear whether those savings are already reflected in the additional opex figure, or how the five permanent positions fit into it.
We want to be clear that the infrastructure renewal project is not a cost-saving exercise. The 100 kEUR in expected cloud savings for 2028 is a separate initiative from this project. It is therefore not reflected in the EUR 1.4M in additional annual OPEX, though three of the five additional FTEs are (reflecting that they will be directly engaged in this project). The two remaining technology FTEs will also support the new infrastructure but they are not as directly related to the project itself. For 2026 we estimate cloud costs in the Infrastructure domain to be around 775 kEUR. RESILIENCE AND OUR TECHNICAL SETUP We currently have two data centres in the Netherlands. By the end of the project, one of these will be located in another country. These two data centres will have two independent networks rather than our current single interdependent one. When this work is completed, we will be able to expand from there to cover more countries and increase our geographic resilience as needed. It is important to be clear that, aside from RIPE NCC Access, none of our core services are currently running on third-party cloud services. This project is therefore not about moving out of the cloud and into data centres. Instead, it stops further cloud deployments and creates a more sustainable foundation for our services that is modular and can easily scale up to include more data centres in the future. Regarding the timing of our project, we are aiming to build the new architecture as close to the end of life for the existing equipment. With a completely new build we can more easily test the new platform before moving to production. Incremental upgrades of the existing architecture is unfortunately not sustainable. BENEFITS FOR MEMBERS Your last three paragraphs ask about tangible benefits for members. Our aim is primarily to mitigate risks to our operations, while hopefully also contributing to improved performance in the process. It is our view that a RIPE NCC member is effectively paying for five broad things: 1. A trusted registry along with all of the related services for managing Internet number resources. 2. A portfolio of technical infrastructure and operational tools that can help them to operate networks securely and reliably. 3. Shared Internet infrastructure, measurements, routing data and research that individual members would find difficult or inefficient to reproduce themselves, or that would come with higher costs and/or lack of neutrality if provided by a commercial organisation. 4. A functioning technical community, training ecosystem and institutional voice in policy and Internet governance discussions. 5. A secure, resilient and well-governed organisation capable of continuing to provide all of this over the long term. Since cost reduction became more of a focus in recent years, we have had many difficult conversations internally. One aspect we keep coming back to is the cross-reinforcing nature of our activities (e.g. the ability to create unique analyses using our independent measurement tools forms the basis of our engagement with governments). Therefore, our strategic planning requires us to look at our activities holistically. When taken together, they support a set of goals that is very much in our members’ interests, if only because they protect the stability of the system that allows us to continue providing the more narrow set of core membership services you allude to in your mail. Best regards, Simon-Jan and Sjoerd [1] https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/figures/detail/83131ENG?dl=5FA7 <https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/figures/detail/83131ENG?dl=5FA7> * On 21/10/2026 09:58, Kaj Niemi wrote:
Hi,
Thank you for the detailed response.
A 3-5% annual increase in income over five years amounts to roughly 16-28% cumulatively. If this were funded through corresponding increases in membership fees, the annual fee of approximately 1900 eur would rise to around 2200-2450 eur. Thus, RIPE NCC’s income would rise from 42.5M in 2027 to approximately 48-52M by 2031, or 49-54M eur after five annual increases. That is a substantial expansion. Before members are asked to fund it, I would like to see a clear expenditure trajectory, quantified cost-reduction targets, and an explanation of how much of this growth is expected to come from higher fees rather than other income. I appreciate that income growth does not necessarily mean an equivalent fee increase, but the prospect of recurring increases at this level as a member is not something I welcome.
I also spent some time re-reading the 2025 annual and financial reports but could not readily identify RIPE NCC’s total annual cloud expenditure. Could you provide that figure, together with the amount expected to be eliminated by this project? For illustration only, if current cloud expenditure were 1M eur annually, how would the proposed investment compare with continuing the existing deployment, allowing for the equipment replacements you say are necessary in either case? Your reply projects additional annual opex of 1.4M eur from 2028, excluding depreciation, while identifying [cloud] savings of more than 100k annually. It is not clear whether those savings are already reflected in the additional opex figure, or how the five permanent positions fit into it.
I recognize that this proposed project is themed primarily as a resilience project rather than a cost-saving exercise as it does not seem to reduce costs. Instead, it proposes to increase them significantly and committing to increased costs for a significant period of time. Nevertheless, members need a like-for-like comparison of the total costs of the proposed approach and a minimum necessary renewal of the existing infrastructure, together with the additional resilience each provides. As it stands, I cannot reconcile the proposed capital investment and recurring costs with the financial benefits described.
On resilience, I am not either convinced that consolidating services into two data centers in Europe, with the possibility of adding more later, is necessarily preferable to retaining cloud infrastructure. It reduces some dependencies but introduces or concentrates others. What failure scenarios are the proposed design intended to withstand? For example, if both sites are in the Netherlands, how would it cope with a regional disruption such as major flooding affecting the Amsterdam area? Four instances across two data centers do not, by themselves, demonstrate geographical resilience.
Cloud infrastructure is not immune to physical disasters or regional outages either, and moving between regions or providers is certainly not automatic. However, a suitably designed cloud deployment could retain the option to restore services elsewhere without first having to procure and install another set of physical infrastructure. Could you explain how the proposed design compares with a geographically distributed cloud or hybrid alternative in terms of resilience, recovery time, and total cost? In particular, what would it take to restore services outside the two selected sites if both became unavailable, and how much additional investment would that require?
In short, the figures provided do not make a convincing case for this project as a cost-saving exercise, and the resilience argument remains insufficiently explained. I am not opposed to investing in resilience, but I do not yet see why this particular approach justifies the substantial upfront investment and higher recurring costs.
The timing also deserves scrutiny. You note that equipment prices have increased significantly yet propose committing EUR 7.7 M to new infrastructure now. That makes a clear comparison with phased replacement and continued cloud use even more important: what justifies locking in these costs now rather than spreading the investment over time?
I also disagree with describing most of the listed benefits as “tangible” from a member’s perspective. Greater control over infrastructure, retaining expertise and removing technical debt may be worthwhile operational objectives, but they are not, in themselves, tangible benefits to members. Their value needs to be demonstrated through measurable outcomes: better service availability, shorter recovery times, lower costs, or reduced exposure to clearly identified risks. As presented, the list describes intended organizational improvements rather than showing what members will receive in return for the additional expenditure.
From my perspective, the core reason for membership is the allocation and registration of Internet number resources, together with services such as RPKI and the support needed to use those services. Meetings, training, community activities and other services may also provide value, but that value varies considerably between members. Nevertheless, all members contribute to funding them through their fees.
Before treating recurring income increases as a necessity, I would therefore like to see a clearer distinction between what is essential to delivering those core services reliably and securely, and what is discretionary. The question should not simply be how to fund the current scope of activities at a constantly increasing cost, but whether that scope remains appropriate and reflects members’ priorities.
🙂
Kaj
------------------------------------------------------------------------ *From:* Simon-Jan Haytink <simonjh@ripe.net> *Sent:* Wednesday, October 14, 2026 18:30 *To:* members-discuss@ripe.net <members-discuss@ripe.net> *Subject:* [members-discuss] Re: [ncc-announce] [News] Draft Activity Plan and Budget 2027 Published
Dear Kaj,
Thank you for your email and questions, which we’ll respond to in order. Apologies for the time it’s taken to get back to you, this has been an exceptionally busy period.
We will do our best to be brief and focus on the facts, with the understanding that you or others can ask further questions if there are areas where you want more detail.
We will also note that some aspects of our long-term planning for the infrastructure project and financial projections are still being finalised. Some of this might not be ready until the RIPE Meeting / GM, so please bear with us.
When does RIPE NCC expect operations to return to balance, and what changes will get them there?
Under our current planning, which is yet to be finalised, we plan to break even from 2029 onwards.
To get there, we will need to increase income by about 3%-5% annually. This is to allow for staff performance increases in line with expected market development and to keep pace with inflation for non-personnel Operating Expenses (OPEX).
To offset these increases, we are currently exploring realistic cost reduction targets.
What accounts for the increase of staff from 186 in 2024 to 208 in the 2027 budget (incl. EoR), and how much of this is temporary staffing for the infrastructure project?
Generally speaking, budgeted staff increases until now have been about adding capacity to areas where it was most needed to deliver on our strategy. This meant additional capacity for:
- Registry accuracy and sanctions screening (1 FTE)
- ISO compliance efforts (1 FTE)
- Legal compliance (1 FTE)
- Internal Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) experience (1 FTE)
- Project management (2 FTEs)
- IT support and engineering (5.2 FTEs)
- LIR Portal development (4 FTEs)
Six of these positions added were existing long-term consultant roles that became regular FTEs, which was more cost effective and transparent.
For 2027, the proposed increase of 5 FTEs (counted in the list above) will go towards Technology, primarily to support the operation and maintenance of the new infrastructure. We are not expecting these FTEs to be temporary roles, as we will have a bigger footprint to maintain once the project is completed. We are also planning to take on some extra consultancy to support the project on a temporary basis.
The infrastructure renewal may be justified, but I have more questions about its cost after reading the draft than I did before:
Page 17 mentions expected savings of 27K EUR. Surely it can't be all. Is that per month or per year?
That is annually. We are not expecting much in terms of savings while we are building out the new infrastructure and maintaining the current one in parallel. We expect savings from 2028 to be above 100 kEUR, which will largely come from reducing our cloud costs.
While we are of course stepping back from cloud, our priority is to build the new infrastructure and move any key elements out of the cloud. Decisions about other cloud deployments, such as for our measurement services, will be made at a later stage (whether to shift to an EU-based provider or move this back onto our own infrastructure).
The plan includes 7.7M EUR in capital expenditure for infrastructure renewal. What additional data center and IT capital expenditure is expected in each year from 2028 to 2031?
We do expect regular lifetime replacements for existing equipment for services like DNS outside the central data centres, and for replacing user equipment.//Our current estimate is about 650 kEUR in CAPEX annually over 2028-2031. However, this is only an indicative figure as we continue to develop our longer-term budgeting.
Once this infrastructure renewal project is completed, we will need to discuss whether we should further extend our geographical footprint, requiring additional data centres.
The associated operating expenditure appears to be 1.2M EUR in 2027 and at least 1.4M EUR in 2028. What is projected for each year through 2031? Which existing costs will this spending replace?
Additional OPEX is budgeted to be EUR 1.2 M in our 2027 budget, and is then projected to be EUR 1.4 M annually (excluding depreciation) from 2028-2031.
Overall, the 2027 budget will have an additional OPEX of EUR 2.2 M for this project. This leaves us with a difference of EUR 1 M, which will come from decreasing costs as we transition to the new deployment and no longer have to cover the OPEX of various network elements that have been decommissioned.
What resilience does the proposed design provide beyond the lower-cost 5M EUR option? If the proposed approach proves unworkable, what is the fallback?
Our current proposal is four instances across two separate data centres. EUR 5 M mentioned at the last RIPE Meeting was a rough estimate based on our previous investments, not on current equipment prices, which have increased significantly recently.
Page 18 discusses using Clearing House reserves - what would using them leave as a reserve buffer?
The Clearing House reserve is something we have built over time and is there to provide both short and long-term stability for the RIPE NCC. Earlier this year, we published a document which outlines the goals of the reserve: _https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-860/_ <https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-860/>
Our reserve is currently sitting at around EUR 34 M. Our current projections for a five year financial plan involve running a deficit from 2027-2028, breaking even in 2029, and making a surplus from 2030-3031. We estimate that our reserves would be back at around current levels by the end of this five year cycle.
Of course, this would depend on the outcome of successive membership redistribution votes, since the GM decides whether the deficit or surplus for a given year is added to our reserves or returned to members.
What is the opportunity cost for this proposed project?
The direct opportunity cost is the interest that we would otherwise earn on these funds. We plan to pay for this investment using cash we hold in bank deposits, which currently earn 0.75-1.5% interest, while retaining our investment portfolio. Using a rate of 1% for the sake of illustration, EUR 10 M retained in the deposits for a full year would generate 100 kEUR in interest.
It is important to highlight that even if we were to cancel this project, we will have to significantly invest in CAPEX simply to keep with the status quo. Somewhere on the order of 50% of the proposed EUR 7.7 M spend is needed to replace existing equipment that is already at the end of its lifespan.
I would also like a bit more color on the 2.2M EUR office renovation. What kind of work does it cover? > Will the landlord contribute, or will RIPE NCC pay the full amount? > What would be the cost per sqm?
We have been at our current location for ten years and have not made any significant investment in the office over this time. We have also postponed making some repairs as the decision to stay in the building had not been made. However, after looking at alternatives in 2025, we decided to remain in the building for another ten years.
To be more specific about what is involved here:
On the renovation side:
- There are some changes required to mitigate health and safety, and security risks
- Our office design predates COVID, and working styles have changed significantly since then – with more video calls and hosting or participation in hybrid events, there is a greater need for quiet areas and privacy booths, and to address noise overall.
On the repair side:
- Repairs are needed to the floor in places
- There are technical issues with our current lighting, which is also no longer supported
- Some furniture needs to be replaced
We are negotiating with our landlord to ensure they cover what they are contractually obligated to. The landlord has already completed extensive external renovations (windows, roofs) and replaced central parts of the ventilation system. Unfortunately, we expect that we will need to pay most of the remaining cost ourselves.
The cost per square metre is EUR 759. Market renovation costs for a hybrid office setup in the Netherlands at a quality level defined as ‘comfort’ are around EUR 1,050 per sqm. This makes for a tight budget, but we think we can manage.
Spreading the cost over nine years for accounting purposes does not change the upfront cash requirement. The quoted 12 EUR per LIR per year describes the annual depreciation, not what RIPE NCC must spend on the renovation. The same distinction applies to the infrastructure project: allocating its cost across LIRs over five years does not show how it will be funded or what it will cost to operate. Depreciation is relevant to the income statement and the asset's carrying value on the balance sheet, but it does not show when the cash is spent, which is much more interesting in our opinion.
To finance the investments, we would either need an external loan or to spend cash from our reserves. From our 2025 audited financial report, our available cash at year-end was EUR 32.6 M. In 2026, we moved EUR 16 M of that to our investment portfolio, meaning that we still have EUR 16 M of non-working capital in cash.
While we are investigating leasing possibilities for the equipment, our recommendation to the board will most likely be to finance the investment from our cash in the bank.
In our budget, we estimate CAPEX cash spending for the first 50% of the EUR 7.7 M infrastructure renewal project will take place on 1 January 2027 and the second 50% on 30 June 2027.
We estimate the start of the office investment depreciation to be from 1 September 2027, which is when we expect the renovation to be completed. The cash-out for this is expected to be spread across Q1, Q2 and Q3 2027.
Finally, I am concerned about the prospect of another membership fee increase. If members are asked to vote on higher fees again next spring, how does RIPE NCC expect to fund these plans without raising fees year after year?
As mentioned above, we expect we will need to increase our income by 3-5% per year to cover general cost increases. We are looking into the right balance between using reserves and cost reductions to minimise the additional burden on members as much as possible.
There are also the outstanding recommendations from the Charging Scheme Task Force that need to be discussed with the membership, which could potentially result in a more fair way of distributing costs among members (e.g. on the basis of usage of services such as a transfer fee).
What tangible benefit will members receive in return for the additional cost? Please don't take it the wrong way, but I'm very concerned that the membership exists for RIPE NCC and not NCC existing for us.
The main benefit of this project is resilience: the ability to recover from a serious disaster.
Looking at the environment around us, certain shared assumptions about levels of cooperation, about the resilience of the wider system we are a part of, and about the relations between various countries within our service region may not continue to hold. After extensive discussions with our board, we believe it is worth taking action to secure our operations now – while the RIPE NCC has adequate funds, a committed staff, and enough support from the membership to implement such a project.
While being mindful of the financial pressure that many members are under and respecting their expressed desire to keep costs under control, we nevertheless remain firmly convinced that the RIPE NCC continues to deliver well on its mission and provides considerable value to its members. Even with the addition of this significant investment, we plan to keep our income increase close to inflation.
In terms of tangible benefits, our infrastructure renewal project will provide the following:
- Lower dependency on individual external/cloud providers
- Fewer critical infrastructure dependencies
- Better recovery options when things go wrong
- Greater RIPE NCC control over the infrastructure supporting member services
- Greater geographical resilience
- Reduced exposure to geopolitical or regulatory changes
- Removal of accumulated technical debt
- More maintainable infrastructure
- Retention of critical technical expertise within the RIPE NCC
- More predictable control over future operating costs
- A platform capable of supporting RIPE NCC services throughout the 2027-2031 strategy period
Finally, we want to thank you for your thoughtful response and for starting the discussion here in a constructive way as we head into the upcoming RIPE Meeting. It is precisely this point in the process where members should be asking these sorts of questions, voicing concerns and making suggestions. So please, members, speak up. We need to find a rough consensus here on a path forward so our people can get to work.
Kind regards
Simon-Jan Haytink Chief Financial Officer RIPE NCC And Sjoerd Wolthers Chief Technology Officer RIPE NCC
On 01/10/2026 17:02, Kaj Niemi wrote:
Hi,
Okay, I’ll bite.
The plan shows a 1.7M EUR operating deficit, partly offset by 0.6M EUR in budgeted financial income, leaving a net deficit of 1.1M EUR. When does RIPE NCC expect operations to return to balance, and what changes will get them there?
If I have the figures right, RIPE NCC had 182 FTEs and four EoR staff in 2024. The 2027 budget puts the combined figure at around 208. What accounts for that increase, and how much of it is temporary staffing for the infrastructure project?
The infrastructure renewal may be justified, but I have more questions about its cost after reading the draft than I did before:
* Page 17 mentions expected savings of 27K EUR. Surely it can't be all. Is that per month or per year? * The plan includes 7.7M EUR in capital expenditure for infrastructure renewal. What additional data center and IT capital expenditure is expected in each year from 2028 to 2031? * The associated operating expenditure appears to be 1.2M EUR in 2027 and at least 1.4M EUR in 2028. What is projected for each year through 2031? Which existing costs will this spending replace? * What resilience does the proposed design provide beyond the lower-cost 5M EUR option? If the proposed approach proves unworkable, what is the fallback? * Page 18 discusses using Clearing House reserves. As I understand it, these reserves were built largely from past membership fees (while the same paragraph implies there are plenty of alternatives to raising it via membership fees.......) Is that correct, and what would using them leave as a reserve buffer? * What is the opportunity cost for this proposed project?
I would also like a bit more color on the 2.2M EUR office renovation.
* What kind of work does it cover? * Will the landlord contribute, or will RIPE NCC pay the full amount? * What would be the cost per sqm?
Spreading the cost over nine years for accounting purposes does not change the upfront cash requirement. The quoted 12 EUR per LIR per year describes the annual depreciation, not what RIPE NCC must spend on the renovation. The same distinction applies to the infrastructure project: allocating its cost across LIRs over five years does not show how it will be funded or what it will cost to operate. Depreciation is relevant to the income statement and the asset's carrying value on the balance sheet, but it does not show when the cash is spent, which is much more interesting in my opinion.
Finally, I am concerned about the prospect of another membership fee increase. If members are asked to vote on higher fees again next spring, how does RIPE NCC expect to fund these plans without raising fees year after year?
What tangible benefit will members receive in return for the additional cost? Please don't take it the wrong way, but I'm very concerned that the membership exists for RIPE NCC and not NCC existing for us.
Kaj
------------------------------------------------------------------------ *From:* Hans Petter Holen <hph+announce@ripe.net> <mailto:hph+announce@ripe.net> *Sent:* Wednesday, September 30, 2026 22:08 *To:* ncc-announce@ripe.net <mailto:ncc-announce@ripe.net> <ncc-announce@ripe.net> <mailto:ncc-announce@ripe.net> *Subject:* [ncc-announce] [News] Draft Activity Plan and Budget 2027 Published
Dear members,
The Draft RIPE NCC Activity Plan and Budget 2027 is now available for your review at: https://www.ripe.net/s/gm/oct-2026-supporting-docs/ <https://www.ripe.net/s/gm/oct-2026-supporting-docs/>
This document begins our 2027-2031 strategic cycle and introduces a more streamlined approach to the Activity Plan.
Key budget points for 2027 include: - Income of EUR 42.5 M - Operational costs of EUR 44.2 M - Deficit from operations at EUR 1.7M EUR - Financial Income and Expenditures at EUR 0.6 M - Deficit at EUR 1.1 M - Combined FTE and Employer of Record (EoR) count increasing by 2.5%
The overall budgets for Registry, External Engagement & Community, and Organisational Sustainability remain at the same level as 2026. General personnel increases and inflation have been incorporated, with savings made within these divisions through continuous cost optimisation and control.
The main change is the investment required to renew our technical infrastructure. This project has already started in 2026 and will run until 2028. As a result, capital expenditure will increase from 930 kEUR in the 2026 Budget to EUR 10.5 M in 2027. Included in this total is EUR 2.2 M for repairs and renovations to our offices.
Our budgeted income also reflects the Charging Scheme approved by the membership at the General Meeting in May 2026, including the EUR 1,894 membership fee, the introduction of fees for legacy IPv4 resources and changes to ASN fees.
We have budgeted to start 2027 with 20,000 LIR accounts, the same as in 2026. RIPE NCC expense per LIR is expected to be EUR 2,056, a 7% increase compared to the 2026 Budget.
Please read the document and share any feedback on members-discuss@ripe.net <mailto:members-discuss@ripe.net>.
The document was approved for publication by the Executive Board at its 196th meeting: https://www.ripe.net/about-us/executive-board/minutes/executive-board-minute... <https://www.ripe.net/about-us/executive-board/minutes/executive-board-minutes-2026/196th-executive-board-meeting-minutes/>
The Draft Activity Plan and Budget 2027 will be discussed at the General Meeting (GM) alongside RIPE 93 and in the RIPE NCC Services Working Group on Wednesday, 28 October 2026. The Executive Board will consider all feedback on our activities before approving the final version that will be published in December 2026.
If you would like to participate or vote in the GM, you will need to register. You can find all information about the GM, including the draft agenda and how to register, at: https://www.ripe.net/s/gm/oct-2026/ <https://www.ripe.net/s/gm/oct-2026/>
Kind regards,
Hans Petter Holen, Managing Director and CEO RIPE NCC
To unsubscribe or manage your subscription, log in to the LIR Portal with your RIPE NCC Access account and go to the LIR Account page: https://my.ripe.net/#/account-details <https://my.ripe.net/#/account-details>. Scroll down to Membership Mailing Lists to update your 'members-discuss' subscription. Having issues unsubscribing? More information about managing your subscription can be found at: https://www.ripe.net/s/members-discuss-subscription-options/ <https://www.ripe.net/s/members-discuss-subscription-options/>