Hi, On Tue, Mar 3, 2020, at 19:31, JORDI PALET MARTINEZ via routing-wg wrote:
I don't think I'm the one that should calculate that. However, if we have an alternative proposal with the SLURM file, it can be calculated (approximately) as part of the analysis impact that will be needed as well, right?
May be anyone from the community that already has done that job and integrated the SLURM in their routers, can provide an estimate cost, and then multiply it for the number of all the RIRs members?
I believe (I may be wrong) that the AS0 is much cheaper to implement by RIPE NCC even if it is several thousand euros, than the number of worldwide folks that will need to use the SLURM in addition to RPKI (for non-AS0).
Let me rephrase: what is the cost to the community of no implementation of 2019-08 at all? It has been mentioned before that 2019-08 in its current shape seems way too big of a hammer for the problem it claims to solve. I personally consider a SLURM file a good middle-ground, but if it boils down either using the RPKI for this or nothing, the latter option is what I support. Kind regards, Job