July 2016 - RIRs-LEA - mailman.ripe.net

RIR/LEA Mailing list
by Richard Leaning 12 Jul '16

12 Jul '16

Hi Cesar, Welcome to the mailing list. Cheers Dick Richard Leaning External Relations RIPE NCC > On 11 Jul 2016, at 21:20, Kevon Swift <kevon(a)lacnic.net> wrote: > > Hi Richard, > > One last inclusion on our end - my colleague Cesar Díaz (cesar(a)lacnic.net <mailto:cesar@lacnic.net>) who also has default responsibility for Central America and engagement in some processes in which LEA interaction may be prime. I hope this could also be accommodated! > > Kind regards, > Kevon > > On 10/07/2016 7:49 AM, Richard Leaning wrote: >> Dear Carlos, >> >> Welcome to the list. >> >> Kind Regards >> >> Dick >> >> >> Richard Leaning >> External Relations >> RIPE NCC >> >> >> >> >>> On 8 Jul 2016, at 08:31, Oscar A. Robles-Garay <oscar(a)lacnic.net> <mailto:oscar@lacnic.net> wrote: >>> >>> Richard, >>> >>> Could you include Carlos Martínez, our CTO to this ML? >>> >>> Thanks! >>> >>> Oscar >>> >>> >>> On 7/2/16 11:54, Richard Leaning wrote: >>>> Dear All, >>>> >>>> I have opened this mailing list after the feedback I had during ICANN56 last week. This mailing list is a private list for RIR staff only, who engage with LEA on a regular basis or who are looking to do so. >>>> >>>> The members at present are >>>> >>>> Dick >>>> Chris B >>>> Marco H >>>> Leslie >>>> Craig >>>> Allen >>>> Kevon >>>> Oscar >>>> Vymala >>>> >>>> I am the administrator for the list, so can you please let me know who else I need to add. >>>> >>>> I would like this list to be used for the following. But please suggest more. >>>> >>>> 1. Update each other on what's happening in our regions with regards LEA, including invites we receive to attend LEA meetings and who is going to what. >>>> 2. Coordinate LEA training and share ideas on what works and what doesn't, even share training materials and presentations. >>>> 3. Coordinate the latest PDP proposal from LEAs, which I know Leslie will circulate the minutes of that meeting very soon. >>>> >>>> As I said this is just my suggestions - but the list can be basically used for anything to do with LEAs but please feel free to add anything. >>>> >>>> Can you all just bing me back a quick reply so I know it's working. >>>> >>>> Cheers >>>> >>>> Dick >>>> >>>> Richard Leaning >>>> RIPE NCC >>>> External Relations >>>> >>>> _______________________________________________ >>>> RIRs-LEA mailing list >>>> RIRs-LEA(a)ripe.net <mailto:RIRs-LEA@ripe.net> >>>> https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/rirs-lea <https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/rirs-lea> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> RIRs-LEA mailing list >> RIRs-LEA(a)ripe.net <mailto:RIRs-LEA@ripe.net> >> https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/rirs-lea <https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/rirs-lea> >

1 0

Re: [RIRs-LEA] RIR/LEA Mailing list
by Richard Leaning 11 Jul '16

11 Jul '16

Dear Carlos, Welcome to the list. Kind Regards Dick Richard Leaning External Relations RIPE NCC > On 8 Jul 2016, at 08:31, Oscar A. Robles-Garay <oscar(a)lacnic.net> wrote: > > Richard, > > Could you include Carlos Martínez, our CTO to this ML? > > Thanks! > > Oscar > > > On 7/2/16 11:54, Richard Leaning wrote: >> Dear All, >> >> I have opened this mailing list after the feedback I had during ICANN56 last week. This mailing list is a private list for RIR staff only, who engage with LEA on a regular basis or who are looking to do so. >> >> The members at present are >> >> Dick >> Chris B >> Marco H >> Leslie >> Craig >> Allen >> Kevon >> Oscar >> Vymala >> >> I am the administrator for the list, so can you please let me know who else I need to add. >> >> I would like this list to be used for the following. But please suggest more. >> >> 1. Update each other on what's happening in our regions with regards LEA, including invites we receive to attend LEA meetings and who is going to what. >> 2. Coordinate LEA training and share ideas on what works and what doesn't, even share training materials and presentations. >> 3. Coordinate the latest PDP proposal from LEAs, which I know Leslie will circulate the minutes of that meeting very soon. >> >> As I said this is just my suggestions - but the list can be basically used for anything to do with LEAs but please feel free to add anything. >> >> Can you all just bing me back a quick reply so I know it's working. >> >> Cheers >> >> Dick >> >> Richard Leaning >> RIPE NCC >> External Relations >> >> _______________________________________________ >> RIRs-LEA mailing list >> RIRs-LEA(a)ripe.net >> https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/rirs-lea >

2 1

RIPE Meeting Oct.
by Richard Leaning 08 Jul '16

08 Jul '16

Hi All, Thanks Leslie and Kevon for the update. Yes, Greg Mounier, EC3 (Europol) with our help as already presented on this topic at the last RIPE meeting at the AAWG. He is intending to present again at the meeting in October in Madrid - (24th - 28th Oct). He has the support of the Chair of the AAWG to present and we will make sure he submits it through the right channels - i.e - The RIPE Programme Committee (PC) who are responsible for ensuring that the RIPE Meeting programme consists of interesting, relevant and inspiring content. Cheers Dick Richard Leaning External Relations RIPE NCC > On 6 Jul 2016, at 15:23, mailman-bounces(a)ripe.net wrote: > > The attached message was received as a bounce, but either the bounce > format was not recognized, or no member addresses could be extracted > from it. This mailing list has been configured to send all > unrecognized bounce messages to the list administrator(s). > > For more information see: > https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/admin/rirs-lea/bounce > > > From: Leslie Nobile <leslien(a)arin.net> > Subject: Following up > Date: 6 July 2016 at 15:20:58 GMT-5 > To: RIRs-LEA <rirs-lea-bounces(a)ripe.net> > > > Hi All- > > I just wanted to send a quick email to let you know that I had a call today with FBI folks (Bobby and Iranga) to discuss next steps. They are still working on the policy text based on input they received last week from various community members, ASO reps, and RIR staff. Our discussion today centered on how the LEAs should go about getting added to the agendas of our upcoming fall RIR meetings in order to introduce the topic of the importance of Whois accuracy from a LEA perspective. I advised them to write a short abstract introducing their intended topic and to send it to me. I will work on getting this added to the agenda for the ARIN fall meeting. > > They asked how this would happen in the other regions, which is why I am bringing this to your attention. I believe that they have already identified LEA counterparts for the Ripe region (Greg Mounier) and for the APNIC region (Jeremy from South Korea?), but they are still working on finding someone in the Lacnic and Afrinic regions. In any event, do you all have any advice as to how they should approach getting on to your fall meeting agendas? And are there any particular deadlines they need to be aware of right now with regards to getting added to your meeting agendas? > > Thanks. > > Best, > Leslie > > > >

1 0

Re: [RIRs-LEA] Fwd: Following up
by Kevon Swift 08 Jul '16

08 Jul '16

Hi all, We can assign them a Topics of Interest slot during our Policy Forum at LACNIC26 (Sept 26-30). Re the counterpart, our Policy Officer Gianina (cc'd) can put Bobby or Iranga in touch with someone from our community to take the proposal from there. If it's a question of submitting text for the meeting the usual 4wk lead time would apply but from what I recall, the policy submissions/consensus building will be for our early year Policy Forums in 2017, correct? Regards, Kevon Swift Líder de Relaciones Estratégicas e IntegraciónHead of Strategic Relations and Integration LACNIC - www.lacnic.netLatin American and Caribbean Internet Addresses Registry-------- Original message --------From: Richard Leaning <rleaning(a)ripe.net> Date: 06/07/2016 5:16 pm (GMT-04:00) To: RIRs-LEA <RIRs-LEA(a)ripe.net> Subject: [RIRs-LEA] Fwd: Following up Richard LeaningRIPE NCCExternal Relations Begin forwarded message: From: Leslie Nobile <leslien(a)arin.net> Date: 6 July 2016 at 21:20:58 BST To: RIRs-LEA <rirs-lea-bounces(a)ripe.net> Subject: Following up Hi All- I just wanted to send a quick email to let you know that I had a call today with FBI folks (Bobby and Iranga) to discuss next steps. They are still working on the policy text based on input they received last week from various community members, ASO reps, and RIR staff. Our discussion today centered on how the LEAs should go about getting added to the agendas of our upcoming fall RIR meetings in order to introduce the topic of the importance of Whois accuracy from a LEA perspective. I advised them to write a short abstract introducing their intended topic and to send it to me. I will work on getting this added to the agenda for the ARIN fall meeting. They asked how this would happen in the other regions, which is why I am bringing this to your attention. I believe that they have already identified LEA counterparts for the Ripe region (Greg Mounier) and for the APNIC region (Jeremy from South Korea?), but they are still working on finding someone in the Lacnic and Afrinic regions. In any event, do you all have any advice as to how they should approach getting on to your fall meeting agendas? And are there any particular deadlines they need to be aware of right now with regards to getting added to your meeting agendas? Thanks. Best, Leslie

8 12

Fwd: Following up
by Richard Leaning 06 Jul '16

06 Jul '16

Richard Leaning RIPE NCC External Relations Begin forwarded message: > From: Leslie Nobile <leslien(a)arin.net> > Date: 6 July 2016 at 21:20:58 BST > To: RIRs-LEA <rirs-lea-bounces(a)ripe.net> > Subject: Following up > > Hi All- > > I just wanted to send a quick email to let you know that I had a call today with FBI folks (Bobby and Iranga) to discuss next steps. They are still working on the policy text based on input they received last week from various community members, ASO reps, and RIR staff. Our discussion today centered on how the LEAs should go about getting added to the agendas of our upcoming fall RIR meetings in order to introduce the topic of the importance of Whois accuracy from a LEA perspective. I advised them to write a short abstract introducing their intended topic and to send it to me. I will work on getting this added to the agenda for the ARIN fall meeting. > > They asked how this would happen in the other regions, which is why I am bringing this to your attention. I believe that they have already identified LEA counterparts for the Ripe region (Greg Mounier) and for the APNIC region (Jeremy from South Korea?), but they are still working on finding someone in the Lacnic and Afrinic regions. In any event, do you all have any advice as to how they should approach getting on to your fall meeting agendas? And are there any particular deadlines they need to be aware of right now with regards to getting added to your meeting agendas? > > Thanks. > > Best, > Leslie > >

1 0

Notes from our meeting with LEAs in Helsinki
by Leslie Nobile 04 Jul '16

04 Jul '16

Hi All- Below you will find notes from our meeting with LEAs in Helsinki where we discussed how LEAs can move forward on a globally coordinated policy that can be presented in all 5 regions. These notes are fairly general and do not contain a great deal of detail. If those who attended the meeting feel that there is some important detail missing, please let me know and I can adjust. Best, Leslie LEA - RIR Meeting June 29, 2016 Attendees: Bobby Flaim (FBI) Iranga Kahangama (FBI) Dirk Ballou (DEA) Thomas Walden (DEA) Catherine Bauer-Bulst (European Commission) Laura Kate-Bernstein (DoJ attorney) Greg Mounier (Europol) Kimmo Ulkulniemi (Interpol) Craig Ng (APNIC) Alan Barret (Afrinic) Leslie Nobile (ARIN) Kevon Swift (Lacnic) Oscar Robles (Lacnic) Dick Leaning (Ripe NCC) Chris Buckridge (Ripe NCC) Purpose of meeting: The purpose of the meeting was to discuss how LEAs plan on moving forward on a globally coordinated WHOIS Accuracy Policy to be proposed at each RIR. The FBI has created an initial policy proposal on behalf of law enforcement/consumer protection agencies that they will use as a starting point. They will be soliciting input from representatives (community members, LEAs) from each region in order to eventually finalize a globally coordinated policy that can be proposed in each region. Discussion Points: * Introduction of the topic by Bobby Flaim * Short presentation of Whois accuracy practices/policies at each RIR (Leslie Nobile) * Discussion of the issues and the way forward, with questions from the LEA reps and input from each RIR. * All RIRs provided some general feedback on the initial policy proposal. Feedback mainly focused on the policy process in each region and guidelines on how to propose a policy, but did not delve into the specifics of the policy criteria. Way Forward: * It was decided that there is not enough time to finalize a proposal in time for the fall round of RIR meetings, so they will aim for having it ready in time for the spring RIR meetings. The preference is to have the best possible proposal rather than trying to rush through a half-baked proposal. * The first step will be to get a community member from each region to work with an LEA rep from that region and have them act as "co-shepherds" of the policy proposal in their respective regions. * The RIRs (those of us who act as LEA liaisons) will work with their respective LEA rep in order to get them on the agenda of their next RIR meeting so that they can introduce the topic and socialize the idea of a globally coordinated policy. * LEA reps will take all input, including the input they have received thus far from members of the community in several regions, and will rework the proposal.

1 0

Test
by Richard Leaning 04 Jul '16

04 Jul '16

Richard Leaning RIPE NCC External Relations

3 2

RIR/LEA Mailing list
by Richard Leaning 02 Jul '16

02 Jul '16

Dear All, I have opened this mailing list after the feedback I had during ICANN56 last week. This mailing list is a private list for RIR staff only, who engage with LEA on a regular basis or who are looking to do so. The members at present are Dick Chris B Marco H Leslie Craig Allen Kevon Oscar Vymala I am the administrator for the list, so can you please let me know who else I need to add. I would like this list to be used for the following. But please suggest more. 1. Update each other on what's happening in our regions with regards LEA, including invites we receive to attend LEA meetings and who is going to what. 2. Coordinate LEA training and share ideas on what works and what doesn't, even share training materials and presentations. 3. Coordinate the latest PDP proposal from LEAs, which I know Leslie will circulate the minutes of that meeting very soon. As I said this is just my suggestions - but the list can be basically used for anything to do with LEAs but please feel free to add anything. Can you all just bing me back a quick reply so I know it's working. Cheers Dick Richard Leaning RIPE NCC External Relations

2 1

Test
by richard leaning 02 Jul '16

02 Jul '16

1 0