April 2025 - ripe-list - mailman.ripe.net

Consultation on Draft “Governance Document for the Recognition, Maintenance, and Derecognition of Regional Internet Registries”
by Ulka Athale 06 May '25

06 May '25

Dear colleagues, This message is sent on behalf of the Number Resource Organization Number Council (NRO NC) The announcement can be viewed at: https://www.nro.net/consultation-on-draft-governance-document-for-the-recog… ----------------------------------------- The NRO NC has published a draft version of a document that aims to update ICP-2: Criteria for Establishment of New Regional Internet Registries. This updated document is titled “Governance Document for the Recognition, Maintenance, and Derecognition of Regional Internet Registries” (RIR Governance Document) and can be viewed here: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/rir-governance-do… We now invite your input on this draft. Please make sure to share your feedback by Tuesday, 27 May 2025 on your regional consultation list. ----------------------------------------- Background Information ----------------------------------------- In October 2023, the Number Resource Organization Executive Council (NRO EC) asked the NRO Number Council (NRO NC), that fulfils the role of the Address Supporting Organization Address Council (ASO AC), to establish and manage a process to update the Internet Coordination Policy (ICP-2): Criteria for Establishment of New Regional Internet Registries document [1]. Modification of ICP-2 requires an open and transparent process to allow participation from across the global RIR and ICANN communities. As part of this process, the NRO NC invited the global Regional Internet Registry (RIR) communities to provide feedback on each principle via a questionnaire, which was open from 8 October until 6 December 2024 [2]. On 24 February 2025, the NRO published a qualitative analysis and summary of the community responses received on the proposed principles to update ICP-2 [3]. The updated criteria will continue to reflect the fundamental principles required for recognizing and evaluating new RIRs in keeping with the Internet landscape of today. There is no intention to fundamentally change or redesign the existing RIR system. The focus of the review and revision process is to identify existing gaps and areas of improvement to support the continued stability and self-governance of the Internet Numbers Registry System. This includes expanding or adding details related to governance, ecosystem, life cycle, recognition and operation of RIRs. It also outlines principles for the potential ‘derecognition’ of an RIR if it fails to adhere to the established criteria. ----------------------------------------- Share Your Input ----------------------------------------- The NRO NC is now seeking community input on the new draft text of the proposed “RIR Governance Document”. This feedback will be reviewed by the NRO NC during their workshop scheduled during ICANN 83 in June. We ask you to please keep the following in mind while preparing your comments: - Please share feedback that is specific to this draft - We are particularly interested in hearing your views on the new requirements in the draft - Whether the draft provides sufficient clarity regarding the ongoing obligations of an RIR and the remediation steps if the obligations are not met - This document does not address the implementation of the RIR criteria; comments on implementation will be considered out of scope - Constructive comments are highly appreciated To participate, please follow the consultations in your region listed on the Community Engagements web page: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/community-engagem… ----------------------------------------- Join a Session ----------------------------------------- All the planned sessions during which we will share information on the draft “RIR Governance Document” and the process to update ICP-2 will be listed on the NRO website. The sessions will also be recorded and archived, links to the recordings will also be listed on the same webpage: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/community-engagem… Regards, The NRO Secretariat [1] https://www.icann.org/resources/pages/new-rirs-criteria-2012-02-25-en [2] https://www.nro.net/the-nro-invites-internet-community-to-participate-in-ic… [3] https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/icp-2-principles-… ----------------------------------------- For further reference, the timeline and process to review ICP-2 is available here: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/process-for-the-r… Kind regards, Ulka Athale RIPE NCC www.ripe.net

7 7

Feedback on the Draft Governance Document for RIR Recognition and Derecognition
by Abdulrahman Almousa 29 Apr '25

29 Apr '25

Dears, After a review of the “Governance Document for the Recognition, Maintenance, and Derecognition of Regional Internet Registries” draft, I would like to submit the following feedback: *1. Insufficient Clarity Regarding Regional Continuity After Derecognition* *Observation:* The draft outlines the procedures for derecognizing an RIR but *does not provide clarity* on how continuity of Internet number resource management will be maintained in the affected region after derecognition. *Impact:* The absence of a predefined transitional or fallback mechanism poses operational risks for resource holders in the affected region and may jeopardize Internet infrastructure stability at a regional level. *Recommendation:* Including a clear provision specifying: - An obligation to guarantee service continuity for affected resource holders, - A framework for temporary stewardship or reassignment of responsibilities to an interim or existing RIR, - A stakeholder consultation process to guide regional transition planning. This addition would align with the draft's stated goal of safeguarding the reliability and neutrality of the Internet number registry system. *2. Concerns About the Requirement for Unanimous RIR Support for New RIR Recognition* *Observation:* Section 2.3(c) implies that *unanimous support* from all existing RIRs is necessary before forwarding a Candidate RIR proposal to ICANN for final approval. *Impact:* Requiring unanimous agreement effectively grants any single RIR the power to veto the recognition of a new RIR, regardless of demonstrated regional need or readiness. This could inhibit the natural evolution of the registry system, particularly in underserved or emerging regions that meet the technical and governance standards. *Recommendation:* Revising the requirement to allow for a *qualified majority* (e.g., three out of five RIRs) within the NRO Executive Council for forwarding a recognition proposal to ICANN. This change would uphold the principles of collaborative governance without unduly blocking legitimate initiatives. BR, Abdulrahman

1 0

Community Consensus on The Relationship between RIPE and the RIPE NCC
by Mirjam Kuehne 28 Apr '25

28 Apr '25

Dear colleagues, The Last Call for v2 of the draft document The Relationship between RIPE and the RIPE NCC [1] ended earlier this week. We received two small suggestions that helped to improve language and clarity [2]. I am therefore declaring consensus on this document and will ask the RIPE NCC to publish it as a RIPE document. Kind regards, Mirjam Kühne RIPE Chair [1] Draft: The Relationship between RIPE and the RIPE NCC v2 https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-documents/other-documents/draft… [2] Changes since v2 of the document: - In section 3 we replaced "vis-a-vis" with "with respect to" - In section 4 we removed the word "big"

1 1

Join us for the RIPE NCC Open House: Updating ICP-2
by Ulka Athale 24 Apr '25

24 Apr '25

Dear colleagues, We invite you to join our online session, "RIPE NCC Open House: Updating ICP-2" with Hervé Clément, Andrei Robachevsky and Constanze Bürger, the NRO NC representatives from the RIPE NCC service region. This session will take place on Tuesday, 29 April at 11:00 CEST (09:00 UTC) Registration is open to all and free: https://www.ripe.net/meetings/open-house/updating-icp-2/ If you would like to add this event to your calendar, please use the link below: https://www.ripe.net/meetings/calendar/ripe-ncc-open-house-updating-icp-2/ The Number Resource Organization Number Council (NRO NC) recently published the draft "RIR Governance Document" intended to update ICP-2, the document that establishes the criteria to recognise Regional Internet Registries: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/rir-governance-do… There is a community consultation open until Tuesday, 27 May 2025, being held in parallel with an ICANN Public Comment process. Your feedback is also welcome on the RIPE Discussion list as part of the RIPE community consultation. We hope to see you at the Open House! Kind regards, Ulka Athale RIPE NCC www.ripe.net

1 0

RIPE support for CVE foundation
by Michael Richardson 23 Apr '25

23 Apr '25

from a private thread: }The CVE Foundation has been formed to fund the CVE effort, due to }"longstanding concerns among members of the CVE Board about the }sustainability and neutrality of a globally relied-upon resource being tied }to a single government sponsor.": } } https://www.thecvefoundation.org/ I had previous opioned that it was time for EC/EU (maybe NATO) to take on funding this, and to move/replicate the effort outside of MITRE. That was before I knew of the foundation. I think that MITRE has done the best job possible ... for a beltway entity... but that it hasn't been very helpful. 3h webinar required to learn what a CVE is before you can get allocations. yes, useful to the unwashed C* masses... I'm of the opinion that RIPE can and ought to take on a role here as representatives of the ISP operator community. Both in a leadership role and as a source of funding. The FAQ says to contact info(a)thecvefoundation.org, and this email is BCC'ed to them. (Many open source projects get dozens to hundreds of "potential" CVEs from fuzzers who need a CVE number assigned in order to claim a bounty. There is now a cottage industry of fuzzers. It's a perverse result of the bounty programs... creating a huge amount of work to review potential issues, which often are impossible to actually exploit... and never come with fixes) -- Michael Richardson <mcr+IETF(a)sandelman.ca> . o O ( IPv6 IøT consulting ) Sandelman Software Works Inc, Ottawa and Worldwide

5 5

Publication of the RIPE Chair/Vice-chair nominees
by RIPE NomCom Chair 16 Apr '25

16 Apr '25

Dear RIPE community, The RIPE 2025 NomCom will select two persons for the roles of RIPE Chair and RIPE Vice Chair. We have five nominees who are well known to the community. They are, in the order of their nomination: Ferghas McKay, Mirjam Kühne, Olena Kushnir, Anna Wilson and Rob Evans. https://ripenomcom.org/ripe-chair-vice-chair-nominees/ Note that some of them have been nominated for Chair or Vice Chair specifically. We have set out the plans for collecting input from the community. Here is a quick outlook about what the NomCom will do between now and the RIPE meeting, during the meeting and after: Before RIPE 90 During the coming two weeks the NomCom will send some questions to the nominees and prepare for the RIPE meeting. We want to hear input from the community at between now and the end of the RIPE meeting. This is your chance to influence our selection. The best way to reach the whole committee is by e-mail via nomcom at ripenomcom.org. If you prefer you can also contact individual members of the NomCom; you can find them and their mail addresses here. Of course we will treat all input confidentially. To that end we have even set up a dedicated server, so that we can erase the electronic traces of our work as well as possible once we are done. We will also give the nominees the opportunity to publish posts on the NomCom blog. During RIPE 90 We will have an office and hold office hours during all lunch breaks. This is your opportunity to speak in person to the committee or arrange for separate meetings with committee members. We will also roam the hallways and be on hand during the community plenary session. Individual meeting slots will be allocated first-come first served. Mail contact at ripenomcom.org for an appointment. After RIPE 90 We will schedule interviews with the nominees and then make our selection during the following weeks. We will regularly report on our progress on this mailing list and the NomCom blog. After we have made our selection and the Executive Board of the RIPE NCC has confirmed that we properly followed the process set by the community, we will announce the new RIPE Chair and Vice Chair. Then our work will be done. During RIPE91 The new chairs will take over during RIPE91. Jan Žorž Chair RIPE 2025 NomCom

1 0

Feedback on Draft “RIR Governance Document” (ICP-2 Review)
by herve.clement＠orange.com 14 Apr '25

14 Apr '25

Dear colleagues, I am happy to share that the Number Resource Organization Number Council (NRO NC) has published the draft "Governance Document for the Recognition, Maintenance, and Derecognition of Regional Internet Registries" to update ICP-2: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/rir-governance-do… As a part of the Regional Internet Registry (RIR) system, the RIPE community has been called to contribute to the ongoing global multistakeholder discussion on the revision of ICP-2. We invite you to share your feedback on this document via the RIPE Discussion list until Tuesday, 27 May 2025. The feedback received from the RIPE community during this period will be provided to the NRO NC for their consideration during the revision process of the draft RIR Governance Document. We would like to clarify that the updated criteria will continue to reflect the fundamental principles required for recognizing and evaluating new RIRs in keeping with the Internet landscape of today. There is no intention to fundamentally change or redesign the existing RIR system. We ask you to please keep the following in mind while preparing your comments: - Please share feedback that is specific to this draft - We are particularly interested in hearing your views on the new requirements in the draft - Whether the draft provides sufficient clarity regarding the ongoing obligations of an RIR and the remediation steps if the obligations are not met - This document does not address the implementation of the RIR criteria; comments on implementation will be considered out of scope - Constructive comments are highly appreciated ----------------------- Join a Session ----------------------- We invite the RIPE community to join us for the following sessions: - RIPE NCC Open House: Updating ICP-2 Tuesday, 29 April at 11:00 CEST (09:00 UTC) This session will take place online and the RIPE community representatives of the NRO NC will share information on the work done so far and introduce the draft RIR Governance Document. https://www.ripe.net/meetings/open-house/updating-icp-2/ - BoF at RIPE 90 We will hold a BoF at RIPE 90 to hear the community's input on the draft RIR Governance Document. You can register and participate online for free, if you are not attending RIPE 90 in person: https://ripe90.ripe.net/ We, the RIPE NRO NC representatives, Constanze Bürger, Andrei Robachevsky and myself, Hervé Clément, will be available to answer your questions at the online session and at RIPE 90. All the planned sessions during which the NRO NC will share information on the draft “RIR Governance Document” and the process to update ICP-2 will be listed on the NRO website. The sessions will also be recorded and archived, links to the recordings will also be listed on the same webpage. You can follow the community engagements across all regions via the Community Engagements web page: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/community-engagem… For more information about ICP-2, please visit: https://www.nro.net/policy/internet-coordination-policy-2/ Thank you for your participation in this important global Internet discussion and we look forward to hearing your input. Regards, Hervé Clément ASO AC Chair Sent on behalf of the NRO NC ----------------------- Important Dates ----------------------- 14 April: Draft “RIR Governance Document” published 14 April: Consultation on draft document opens 29 April: RIPE NCC Open House: Updating ICP-2 12-16 May: BoF on ICP-2 review during RIPE 90 27 May: Consultation closes 9-12 June: NRO NC reviews input during ICANN 83 ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________ Ce message et ses pieces jointes peuvent contenir des informations confidentielles ou privilegiees et ne doivent donc pas etre diffuses, exploites ou copies sans autorisation. Si vous avez recu ce message par erreur, veuillez le signaler a l'expediteur et le detruire ainsi que les pieces jointes. Les messages electroniques etant susceptibles d'alteration, Orange decline toute responsabilite si ce message a ete altere, deforme ou falsifie. Merci. This message and its attachments may contain confidential or privileged information that may be protected by law; they should not be distributed, used or copied without authorisation. If you have received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete this message and its attachments. As emails may be altered, Orange is not liable for messages that have been modified, changed or falsified. Thank you.

1 0

RIPE NCC Community Projects Fund Discontinued
by Hisham Ibrahim 09 Apr '25

09 Apr '25

Dear colleagues, We have decided to discontinue the RIPE NCC Community Projects Fund (CPF). I would like to briefly explain our thinking here. In 2024 we paused the CPF’s funding cycle so we could review our project management processes and the CPF’s overall effectiveness [1]. Our initial plan, explained in a RIPE Labs article last year, was to hold further discussions with the community on possible future formats for the CPF [2]. However, our review found that to continue delivering the CPF in a meaningful way would require more resources while the direct benefit to members was unclear. We shared these considerations with the RIPE NCC Executive Board at its recent meeting in March and provided a few options with their associated costs. This included the option of restructuring the Community Projects Fund at a smaller scale. Given that challenges would still remain in this approach, the Executive Board agreed with our proposal to discontinue the Fund entirely and approved a corresponding resolution which is available in the recently published Board meeting minutes: https://www.ripe.net/about-us/executive-board/minutes/2025/183rd-executive-… The Community Projects Fund was launched in 2016 to support projects that work for ‘the Good of the Internet’ by enhancing the operations, resilience and sustainability of the Internet. Nearly 50 projects received funding over nine years, with a total of EUR 1.6 million euros distributed. We are proud of the work that the fund has enabled, and we thank everyone who has supported these efforts. It is also important to note that the people who received grants in 2024 and are delivering on their work will not be affected by this. We would also like to thank everyone who has worked with us on the RIPE NCC Community Projects Fund, particularly volunteers from the RIPE community who have worked with us on the Selection Committee and our funding recipients for their efforts to make the Internet better for all. Kind regards, Hisham Ibrahim Chief Community Officer RIPE NCC [1] https://www.ripe.net/about-us/news/ripe-ncc-community-projects-fund-paused-… [2] https://labs.ripe.net/author/alastair_strachan/ripe-ncc-community-projects-…

1 0

Reminder: Register for RIPE 90!
by Meeting Mailbox 02 Apr '25

02 Apr '25

Dear colleagues, RIPE 90 is quickly approaching, and we’re excited to share some important details to help you with your participation. The meeting will take place online and in person at the EPIC SANA Lisboa Hotel, Lisbon, Portugal, from 12 - 16 May 2025. You can register for the meeting at: https://ripe90.ripe.net/attend/register/ ------------------- Ticket Options ------------------- Week ticket: EUR 400 Day ticket: EUR 130 Student (week) ticket: EUR 50 You can find more information about ticket options at: https://ripe90.ripe.net/attend/register/ --------------------- Accommodation --------------------- EPIC SANA Lisboa Hotel Av. Eng. Duarte Pacheco 15, 1070-100 Lisbon, Portugal There is a negotiated rate available for RIPE Meeting attendees, subject to limited availability. To secure your reservation and avoid disappointment, please follow the instructions provided on the official meeting venue website: https://ripe90.ripe.net/attend/meeting-venue/ ---------------------------------------- Call for Presentations and WG Topics ---------------------------------------- The Call for Presentations (CfP) deadline has been extended to 8 April 2025. Lightning talk proposals can be submitted until 2 May 2025. Working groups are also seeking content proposals. Please contact the relevant WG chairs if there is a topic you would like to discuss. More information at: https://ripe90.ripe.net/submit-topic/cfp/ ----------------------- Call for Sponsors ----------------------- If you're interested in sponsoring RIPE 90 and getting your logo onto our digital materials, get in touch. Supporting a RIPE Meeting through sponsorship gives your organisation great exposure in the global Internet community. The sponsorship deadline is on 21 April 2025 if you would like your organization to be featured on our printed material. More information: https://ripe90.ripe.net/about/sponsors/become-a-sponsor/ ------------------ Social Events ------------------ More information about the social events can be found here: https://ripe90.ripe.net/programme/social-events/ -------------------------------- Safety and Accessibility -------------------------------- We want all our attendees to enjoy a safe RIPE Meeting. Please familiarise yourselves with information on health, safety and security: https://ripe90.ripe.net/attend/health-safety-and-security/ If you have any accessibility requirements, please email <meeting(a)ripe.net>. ----------------------------------------- Important Dates and Deadlines ----------------------------------------- 08 Apr: Deadline to submit a talk 09 Apr: Childcare application deadline 15 Apr: Final programme published 21 Apr: Sponsorship deadline 28 Apr: Mentoring application deadline 02 May: Lightning Talk submission deadlined 05 May: Deadline to send recorded presentations to be published on the website 12 – 16 May 2025: RIPE 90 takes place in Lisbon More information on RIPE 90 can be found at: https://ripe90.ripe.net/ We want to ensure a safe and welcoming meeting. The RIPE Code of Conduct applies to all RIPE Meeting attendees, and can be found at: https://ripe90.ripe.net/attend/code-of-conduct/ For the latest meeting updates, follow the #RIPE90 hashtag on social media. Kind regards, RIPE Meetings Organisation Team

1 0