All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is this happening?
All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment randy
All of the measurements of concern are labeled "short_query_experiment" in their "description" field. I am attempting to perform "ping" measurements, resolved on probe, towards a number of common domains. More details: All of the measurements indefinitely return a status of "{"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}" (never done), even if the measurement is in face performed and has results, which makes it very difficult to determine when a measurement has been successfully deployed. On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:30 PM Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> wrote:
All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment
randy
The most recent example of this occurrence I have is experiment #12264107, which has a status of {"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}, returned [] for results, and has 40 responsive / allocated probes of the requested 50. On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:47 PM Marc Anthony Warrior < warrior@u.northwestern.edu> wrote:
All of the measurements of concern are labeled "short_query_experiment" in their "description" field. I am attempting to perform "ping" measurements, resolved on probe, towards a number of common domains.
More details: All of the measurements indefinitely return a status of "{"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}" (never done), even if the measurement is in face performed and has results, which makes it very difficult to determine when a measurement has been successfully deployed.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:30 PM Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> wrote:
All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment
randy
Hi Marc, That happened because of the last weekend message delays issues Chris wrote about yesterday. Your one-off measurement was scheduled and finished before the controllers got the task on execution. The measurements got the status "Forbidden" because there were no reaction from controllers within the one-off lifespan which is ~15 minutes. Finally controllers got the task and probes did the measurements but way later. Therefore you can see RTTs on the Probes tab or https://atlas.ripe.net/api/v2/measurements/12264107/latest. You can get the results from your measurements from the "latest" API or repeat your measurements. Sorry for inconvenience. wbr /vty On 4/24/18 2:10 AM, Marc Anthony Warrior wrote:
The most recent example of this occurrence I have is experiment #12264107, which has a status of {"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}, returned [] for results, and has 40 responsive / allocated probes of the requested 50.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:47 PM Marc Anthony Warrior <warrior@u.northwestern.edu <mailto:warrior@u.northwestern.edu>> wrote:
All of the measurements of concern are labeled "short_query_experiment" in their "description" field. I am attempting to perform "ping" measurements, resolved on probe, towards a number of common domains.
More details: All of the measurements indefinitely return a status of "{"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}" (never done), even if the measurement is in face performed and has results, which makes it very difficult to determine when a measurement has been successfully deployed.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:30 PM Randy Bush <randy@psg.com <mailto:randy@psg.com>> wrote:
> All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are > suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is > this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment
randy
Thank you for your response, Viktor. Is anyone still running into this issue? I looked at the post regarding this weekend's problems having been resolved, so I tried launching new measurements today (April 24, 2018). However, it seems like I'm still only getting Forbidden statuses on all measurements. Regards, Marc On Tue, Apr 24, 2018 at 4:06 AM Viktor Naumov <vnaumov@ripe.net> wrote:
Hi Marc,
That happened because of the last weekend message delays issues Chris wrote about yesterday.
Your one-off measurement was scheduled and finished before the controllers got the task on execution. The measurements got the status "Forbidden" because there were no reaction from controllers within the one-off lifespan which is ~15 minutes.
Finally controllers got the task and probes did the measurements but way later. Therefore you can see RTTs on the Probes tab or https://atlas.ripe.net/api/v2/measurements/12264107/latest.
You can get the results from your measurements from the "latest" API or repeat your measurements.
Sorry for inconvenience. wbr /vty
On 4/24/18 2:10 AM, Marc Anthony Warrior wrote:
The most recent example of this occurrence I have is experiment #12264107, which has a status of {"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}, returned [] for results, and has 40 responsive / allocated probes of the requested 50.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:47 PM Marc Anthony Warrior < warrior@u.northwestern.edu> wrote:
All of the measurements of concern are labeled "short_query_experiment" in their "description" field. I am attempting to perform "ping" measurements, resolved on probe, towards a number of common domains.
More details: All of the measurements indefinitely return a status of "{"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}" (never done), even if the measurement is in face performed and has results, which makes it very difficult to determine when a measurement has been successfully deployed.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:30 PM Randy Bush <randy@psg.com> wrote:
All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment
randy
Hi Marc, Sorry about that, this is a different issue involving a(nother) race condition in our scheduling code. However, it should be helped by some of the same improvements that we are deploying over the next few days for the larger issue. I will let you know when the changes have been rolled out and ask you if you're still seeing the issues. Regards, Chris On 24/04/2018 23:17, Marc Anthony Warrior wrote:
Thank you for your response, Viktor.
Is anyone still running into this issue? I looked at the post regarding this weekend's problems having been resolved, so I tried launching new measurements today (April 24, 2018). However, it seems like I'm still only getting Forbidden statuses on all measurements.
Regards, Marc
On Tue, Apr 24, 2018 at 4:06 AM Viktor Naumov <vnaumov@ripe.net <mailto:vnaumov@ripe.net>> wrote:
Hi Marc,
That happened because of the last weekend message delays issues Chris wrote about yesterday.
Your one-off measurement was scheduled and finished before the controllers got the task on execution. The measurements got the status "Forbidden" because there were no reaction from controllers within the one-off lifespan which is ~15 minutes.
Finally controllers got the task and probes did the measurements but way later. Therefore you can see RTTs on the Probes tab or https://atlas.ripe.net/api/v2/measurements/12264107/latest.
You can get the results from your measurements from the "latest" API or repeat your measurements.
Sorry for inconvenience. wbr /vty
On 4/24/18 2:10 AM, Marc Anthony Warrior wrote:
The most recent example of this occurrence I have is experiment #12264107, which has a status of {"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}, returned [] for results, and has 40 responsive / allocated probes of the requested 50.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:47 PM Marc Anthony Warrior <warrior@u.northwestern.edu <mailto:warrior@u.northwestern.edu>> wrote:
All of the measurements of concern are labeled "short_query_experiment" in their "description" field. I am attempting to perform "ping" measurements, resolved on probe, towards a number of common domains.
More details: All of the measurements indefinitely return a status of "{"error":{"status":403,"code":104,"detail":"This measurement hasn't yet started or is no longer running","title":"Forbidden"}}" (never done), even if the measurement is in face performed and has results, which makes it very difficult to determine when a measurement has been successfully deployed.
On Mon, Apr 23, 2018 at 4:30 PM Randy Bush <randy@psg.com <mailto:randy@psg.com>> wrote:
> All of my RIPE Atlas measurement requests (pings in this case) are > suddenly failing with a status "title" field value "Forbidden". Why is > this happening?
you might get a better answer if you identified the experiment
randy
participants (4)
-
Chris Amin -
Marc Anthony Warrior -
Randy Bush -
Viktor Naumov