On 01/03/2019 16:14, Robert Kisteleki wrote:
Hello,
On 2019-02-20 09:36, Gert Doering wrote:
Hi,
On Wed, Feb 20, 2019 at 06:52:28AM +0200, Hank Nussbacher wrote:
On Tue, 19 Feb 2019, scg@gibbard.org wrote:
ASN coverage is just 5.6%. That really doesn't give a complete global view for stats. Rather than return money to LIRs every year in their bill, why not state that any LIR running an active probe within their ASN will get a 50Euro credit on their bill? That alone would increase ASN footprint coverage quickly within RIPE. I like that suggestion :-)
(Not sure how that will pan out if we reach 50% of all LIRs, but to get from 5% to 20%, it might definitely be an idea) Interesting idea indeed!
Let me try to address a few points that were mentioned before, perhaps by providing some background information along the way.
The growth rate is indeed slower than in the early days. As with everything, there's no single reason for this. On one hand we had shortage of hardware probes (which is hopefully solved for the moment, see: https://labs.ripe.net/Members/alun_davies/new-ripe-atlas-version-4-probes/do...). On the other hand, it's harder to reach "uncovered" networks and as someone mentioned before, the "the low hanging fruit being pretty saturated".
We measure ASN coverage compared to all ASN-s that announce anything at all, so depending on how hard one wants to argue for having a probe "in every AS", this may or may not need improvement. We're certainly encouraging all our ambassadors and prospective hosts to deploy probes where we don't have them yet. The current application process has a built-in preference for new networks.
For a few years now the procurement of new probes is funded exclusively by sponsors. Therefore we'd be very happy to see more sponsors stepping up.
Finally: the public graph about the number of users shows the total we have so far (meaning users who interacted with RIPE Atlas while they were logged in via RIPE Access). We can, if this is deemed useful, track the number of recent users too (for some definition of recent).
Regards, Robert
And what about the idea to encourage greater ASN coverage by providing a discount on LIR membership for those who have at least one active ASN probe in their ASN? Regards, Hank