Hi Tore,
http://www.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/address-policy-wg/2011-May/005737.htm l
If I read it correctly, the linked to argument is against RPKI as a whole. However, 2013-04 isn't a question on whether we should do RPKI or not, but whether or not our *existing* RPKI stuff should be extended to include non-members.
Correct.
I've got one question though. What is the rationale for the requirement that «the Internet resources reside within the RIPE NCC service region»? I don't see the reason for this. IMHO, any PI/legacy space issued/maintained by the RIPE NCC should be eligible for certification under this policy, no matter where on (or off!) the planet it's being used.
The intention is to provide the services for end-users / organizations within the RIPE NCC service region. That the resources itself are used outside the region can't and I think we shouldn't want to restrict. I'll see how to rephrase that before the review. Regards, Erik Bais