First my email Mohamed@Bubtaina.com is the same as Mohamed.Bubtaina@Bubtaina.com but I send my emails on the run, I think nobody in here never suffered a breach or have had stolen a password or some of the kind in any way, to start with, nobody should talk for in the name of someone else and should be careful of the person submitting the email is actually him. And not someone using his email so to know who everyone is referring to. RIPE, Like IANA, Like ICANN has a set of rules and regulations which we had a general election and agreed on the agenda and on new agreements. Quarterly yearly each has his own personal circumstances which if can’t pay or want to make a different deal would do it directly with RIPE administration, if it needs voting from NCC members then shall it be when they see necessary. If your organisation is registered doesn’t mean it has an LIR I have my subsidiaries as maintainers for my own infrastructure which if it is a problem, I’ll be glad to remove but doesn’t change the fact that they have no resources except me which is the same as my company which is one and not 2 according to my contract that I signed for NCC .whatever the regulations commits to I follow sometimes you don’t notice due to many interferences.but I thought that’s what NCC members stand.s for we work as a network not individual! Why not talk about having each NCC member an HPC dedicated VPN server for us and our work? Wouldn’t that be a good idea! With the Atlas Probe and An Anchor which we could buy also, in collaboration with IANA and ICANN to maybe connect other RIR within we could cut lots of issues and problems and keep and eye on data network flow making sure our iOS aren’t being used for malpractice and fraud and crimes! I that could be the reason why some want to get rid of part of their Resources! They cant keep and eye for data privacy GDPR regulations policies law and other, on 1024 people device application network or someone using illegally their ips right! Well that’s coming from an MBA student with human resource information system and management background.

Bubtaina

On Friday, 20 July 2018, Max Tulyev <maxtul@netassist.ua> wrote:

As I understand people who started that topic:

1. They have several LIRs for one company.

2. Last LIR was opened in 2nd quarter of this year, and payments are QUARTERLY.

3. They wish to transfer resource from ANOTHER LIR (NOT the last one was opened this year).

4. RIPE NCC issued the invoice for that ANOTHER LIR for 1st quarter, when that LIR did not exists.

5. To let the transfer from FIRST LIR, they have to paid for 1st quarter of the SECOND LIR, which was opened in 2nd quarter.

So, it violates points 1 and 2(3) of what you said below (and common sense, of course).

20.07.18 16:32, Christoph Neukirch пише:

Guys,

There is no problem.

What’s so hard to read and understand the rules and policies. It has been written and described multiple times in this thread. And policies has been accepted signing the contract with RIPE NCC.

In simple short words:

For opening a LIR in the middle of the year you have to pay the current and all following quarters for the current year.

If you want to close a LIR, you have to pay at least ONE FULL annual fee for this LIR, no matter if it’s the first year and you would only have to pay for quarters from the creation of the year.

Same applies to your wish to transfer resources.

Annual means once every year, not once in a timeframe including 12 months.

You DON’T pay for resources, you pay for services from RIPE NCC, both sides using policies and rules developed by the RIPE community.

Having said this, I second the opinion to not expect too much sympathy on this topic. And IMHO you’ll achieve the opposite pushing this topic any further.

Best Regards,

Mohamed Ali Bubteina

Tel +44 (0) 20 7862 6331

Cell +44 (0) 747474 0934 - +961 (79) 1111 93

Fax +44 (0) 203 608 0612

Email: Manager@Bubteina.Group

Email: Mohamed@Bubtaina.com

Registered name: Bubtaina Group Limited

Place of registration: England and Wales

Registered number: 08762428

The information in this email is confidential and solely for the use of the intended recipient(s). If you receive this email in error, please notify the sender and delete the email from your system immediately. In such circumstances, you must not make any use of the email or its contents.

Views expressed by an individual in this email do not necessarily reflect the views of Bubtaina Group Limited. The company and its Subsidiaries, complies with the EU-U.S Privacy Shield Framework and Swiss U.S Privacy Shield as set forth by the U.S Department of Commerce and with the Information Commissioner Office in the United Kingdom, regarding use, collection, and retention of any information held and maintained.

Compliance framework with:

Partners and subsidiaries: