The problem I see most frequently with the list of brokers is that people unfamiliar with the community and transfer process take this as a list of approved, trustworthy IPv4 facilitators. This is not always the case, nor is it possible for RIPE to endorse and rate each broker. I know there is a disclaimer on the list but people don't read these warnings, the mere existence on the website acts as an endorsement. Therefore, I would like to see either the list removed or add a way for people to leave reviews. On 12/20/19, 11:10 AM, "members-discuss on behalf of Carlos Friaças via members-discuss" <members-discuss-bounces@ripe.net on behalf of members-discuss@ripe.net> wrote: On Thu, 19 Dec 2019, Hank Nussbacher wrote: > On 19/12/2019 11:17, Christian Kaufmann wrote: > > I vote to keep the list since it is needed and does provide incentive to > brokers to play by the rules. In addition to keeping the list, RIPE NCC > should auto-send a CoC to brokers on an automatic basis once a quarter. Any > broker that the email bounces should be removed from the list. Any broker > that doesn't ACK the auto-email within 5 business days should be removed from > the list. > > Regards, > Hank Hi, I would be flexible about the 5 business days deadline, but what Hank described seems a good approach to me. Regards, Carlos