Hi Jerzy,

I just want to make it very clear that just because the RIPE NCC hasn't done this exact thing in the past doesn't mean that we can't do it now.

The world has changed a lot since the RIPE NCC was created and even in the past decade. The RIPE NCC has to adjust to the changing realities (such as actually having run out of ipv4). That could mean that we need to think about this in different ways than before.

On Fri, 17 Mar 2023, 19:17 J Pawlus, <Jerzy.Pawlus@cyf-kr.edu.pl> wrote:
Hello,


There is no basis for any LIR membership fee to be based on the IPv4
allocated address space and there are several reasons for this:

- RIPE has never charged LIRs for IP addresses
- It is true that at the beginning RIPE membership fee was based on
  categories, as far as I remember: SMALL, MEDIUM, LARGE and EXTRA LARGE,
  but it was because of work required to serve IPv4 resources.
  At that time IPv4 allocation and assignement policies had to be developed,
  every allocation of IPv4 address space to a LIR had to be checked and
  done by RIPE. What is more, if the IPv4 assignement made by a LIR
  to its End User exceeded the LIR Window size such assignement had to be
  checked and approved by the RIPE staff. RevDNS for allocated resources
  had to be made. This work is long gone.
- The amount of work required to serve leftover IPv4 space cannot be compared
  to what it was required before
- As far as I know RIPE does not pay IANA for IPv4 space allocated to Europe
  Region and any attempt of RIPE to require such payment from LIRs should be
  considered major abuse of RIPE mandate as a RIR.


In conclusion, RIPE has always charged its members for Services not an address
space. If a reverse model is to be developed it has to be with IANA cooperation.
But in my opinion it could lead to splitting Internet to many privately
administered parts.

Kind regards,

Jerzy Pawlus
ACK Cyfronet AGH


_______________________________________________
members-discuss mailing list
members-discuss@ripe.net
https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/members-discuss
Unsubscribe: https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/options/members-discuss/me%40cynthia.re