Den 2019-06-09 00:08 skrev "Job Snijders" <job@instituut.net> följande:
This is all great and I agree. However, it is not RIPE NCC's place to dictate what one does on one's servers/services. Unless RIPE NCC has a financial stake in the operation, I'd prefer it if they don't make any evaluations and just do as instructed.
Looking at RFC 1591, I think there are reasons for the NCC to actually evaluate the technical status of name servers to which delegation is sought. (While 1591 mostly is talking about, and has been quoted in, forward DNS operations, it encompasses all delegations from the root, including ARPA and children.) Yes, this should move to dns-wg. I'll send a starting message there. /Måns -- Måns Nilsson SVT +46 8 7848628