Hello, I think it's not a bad idea but the real solution remain RPKI. If transit operator like HE or L3 start to reject INVALID RPKI and some riskly network start to sign theyr route (and it's pretty simple with RIR tools) we can clear a part of the problem quickly. I don't talk about reject unsigned route, but only invalid signed. Also AS blacklisting can be quickly spoofed. What append if someone use hijacked ASN behind it's legit ASN to announce hijacked prefix (not every filters drop that). Best Regards Cedric Rossius Le 01-08-18 à 11:59, Dominic Schallert a écrit :
Dear colleagues,
I’m sure some of you have read about this recent incident; https://bgpstream.com/event/144058 . Nowadays we’re talking about transport security, https-per-default, etc. but the most fundamental parts of the internet such as BGP, are basically broken from a security perspective. While RPKI/ROA/ROV could fix most of the current security-related struggles, their deployment currently competes somewhat with IPv6 - or even worse - and therefore won’t be a practical solution in the forseeable future. Strict IRRDB and route object filtering is complicated (or almost impossible) as well.
So I’m wondering, why can't we just have an automated blacklist like RBL's for mailservers, where all AS'es detected for hijacking prefixes are automatically blacklisted, similiar to Team Cymru's fullbogons feed? The list combined with some scripting could then be used for realtime AS-path filtering at border routers. Delisting of blacklisted ASNs should happen only after a pre-defined amount of time (eg. 14 days) or after paying a fee to a charity/non-profit and providing a statement on the issue which is publicy released. The idea is to hurt those who can’t get their stuff - especially prefix filtering - together.
I still remember the days where everyone complained about RBLs, nowadays almost every mailserver setup relies on them. Sometimes extreme problems require extrem solutions.
Mit besten Grüßen Kind Regards
Dominic Schallert, BA
*schallert.com e.U.* | Hauptstraße 35b, 6800 Feldkirch, Austria FN: 440372g | UID: ATU66209211 | Gerichtsstand: Feldkirch Tel.: +43 680 146 1947 | Fax: +43 134 242 642 616
www.schallert.com <http://www.schallert.com> | office@schallert.com <mailto:office@schallert.com>
_______________________________________________ members-discuss mailing list members-discuss@ripe.net https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/members-discuss Unsubscribe: https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/options/members-discuss/ml%40servperso.com
