March 2026 - members-discuss-unmoderated

FW: [ripe-list] Discussion about Charging Scheme to RIPE NCC Members List
by Tiberiu Gîndu 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

Dear members, Please see attached a positioning document issued by us (ANISP / RoNIX) related to the charging scheme and other conversations that were exchanged on the RIPE community list (example attached). Best regards, Tiberiu Gîndu ANISP / RoNIX -----Original Message----- From: Mirjam Kuehne <mir(a)zu-hause.nl> Sent: Thursday, March 12, 2026 2:27 PM To: RIPE List <ripe-list(a)ripe.net> Subject: [ripe-list] Discussion about Charging Scheme to RIPE NCC Members List Dear colleagues, Please note that conversations related to the RIPE NCC budget and charging scheme should take place on the RIPE NCC members list and not on the RIPE community list: https://www.ripe.net/membership/mail/ripe-ncc-mailing-lists/members-discuss/ Kind regards, Mirjam Kühne (RIPE Chair and List Moderator) ----- To unsubscribe from this mailing list or change your subscription options, please visit: https://mailman.ripe.net/mailman3/lists/ripe-list.ripe.net/ As we have migrated to Mailman 3, you will need to create an account with the email matching your subscription before you can change your settings. More details at: https://www.ripe.net/membership/mail/mailman-3-migration/

2 1

[members-discuss] NCC Charging scheme
by Akayo 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

In my opinion it would not be wise to aggressively audit members. We have 2026 and not 2009. It would cost much money and would lead to cost-intensive lawsuits: Millions of USD for a questionable cause. We should keep things simple: If a LIR with 128-times more IPv4 space only pays 2.7-times (= Model A) or 2.3 times (= Model B) so much we already have found the problem. --Kayo ---------------------------------------------------------------- From: Kaj Niemi <kajtzu(a)basen.net> Sent: Wednesday, 11. Mar 2026 – 17:27 CET +0100 To: Lutz Donnerhacke <L.Donnerhacke(a)iks-service.de> 'members-discuss(a)ripe.net' <members-discuss(a)ripe.net> Michal Krajčírovič <michal(a)krajcirovic.cz> CC: Subject: [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme You can't turn back time. Realistically, I mean. All this silly talk, no offense, of looting and industrial scale falsifying, etc - please. You don't need to be on a waiting list. I get 10+ emails weekly from various brokers offering, unsolicited, blocks of addresses. I can forward some of them to you if you want. The same offer is available to anyone else, too. Kaj ---------------------------------------------------------------- From: Michal Krajčírovič via members-discuss <members-discuss(a)ripe.net> Sent: Wednesday, March 11, 2026 17:23 To: Lutz Donnerhacke <L.Donnerhacke(a)iks-service.de>; 'members-discuss(a)ripe.net' <members-discuss(a)ripe.net> Subject: [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme Hello, I apologize to everyone; what we are discussing here seems absurd to me. Undoubtedly it is the fault of us, the small LIRs, that we do not participate in the voting where the question of how much we should pay is decided. However, the main issue is not being addressed — that IP addresses were historically allocated inefficiently, often based on fabricated addressing plans, and those who obtained them in this way now pay the same as small LIRs, who must purchase IP addresses at high prices. And what does RIPE propose? That they should also pay for a place on the waiting list. I have a different proposal: immediately stop all inter-RIR transfers initiate a complete audit of IP usage in accordance with addressing plans after the audit, return all IPs used in violation of addressing plans (which includes at least all those being sold at various auctions) to the free pool Where are the days when Arne Kiessling was almost shutting down LIRs? When every minor issue and every suspicion of non-compliance was examined? I personally experienced such an audit at one of my former employers. Today nobody cares, and some “CEO of I-don’t-know-what” writes here that he trusts the members. Sure. We have allowed our own registry to be looted. And now small LIRs are supposed to pay the same as large ones. I call on all small LIRs: let us take RIPE back into our own hands, push for votes not only on payment issues but also on a complete audit, and make it the first registry that will have IP addresses again — because it will reclaim them from those who falsified addressing plans in the past on an industrial scale and are now making millions from it. Michal ------ Původní zpráva ------ Od "Lutz Donnerhacke" <L.Donnerhacke(a)iks-service.de> Komu "'members-discuss(a)ripe.net'" <members-discuss(a)ripe.net> Datum 11.03.2026 14:10:47 Předmět [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme +1 for Sebastian Wiesinger and Gert Döring from my side. We are a small ISP and will be hurt by a price increase for PI and AS resources, because we are doing business with them. 75€ are an irrelevant level of pricing. Even 1000€ per year is not that much compared to the other costs we have (personal, energy, licences, taxes, hardware, …). OTOH those independent resources are a burden to all of us, because they require resources at each of our routers: They increase the routing table and we have no option to filter them out (like we could do on traffic engineering at PA space). So I’ve to compare the increasing hardware costs against a „prohibitive” fee. Not an easy decision. Lutz Donnerhacke Von: Sebastian Wiesinger <sebastian.wiesinger(a)noris.de> Gesendet: Mittwoch, 11. März 2026 11:12 An: members-discuss(a)ripe.net Betreff: [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme > On 11. Mar 2026, at 00:36, sdy(a)a-n-t.ru wrote: > > I completely disagree with you. > > I've personally proposed several linear models. I've proposed various risk > scenarios for the NCC and burden on participants. All proposals are being > ignored. Linear models are simply being removed from discussions by the > administration. Why? The MAJORITY of those participating in this > discussion here have spoken about linear models! This gives me reason to > suspect a certain vested interest on the part of the group and those who > set its goals. The majority of those participating in this discussion is not the majority of those reading or voting. There are not a lot of members that are outspoken about linear models. I’m having trouble to understand which group you mean. The RIPE NCC? The charging scheme taskforce? The members? Could you define what you have identified as the group having a vested interest in keeping linear models out of the charging scheme? > You claim IPv4 is closed. Then explain to us why the market price of one > IP address is already reaching $50? Why don't we see free resources, only > rising prices? The prices for IPv4 are falling for a while now. Still there will be no free resources until IPv6 adoption reaches 100%. (Taken from https://auctions.ipv4.global/prior-sales) > The schemes proposed by the working group not only create inequality among > NCC participants; they cement a system in which the majority will pay for > the very profitable business of a small number of NCC participants. This > group of participants has historically acquired vast amounts of address > space, in part by establishing an inadequate distribution model. Although > warnings about the risks of such a "helicopter distribution" of resources > have been voiced repeatedly, it seems as if the group is strictly > advocating for their interests. This is unacceptable! No-one is paying for the profitable business of anyone. Your membership fees are not handed out to other RIPE members. You’re paying for your RIPE NCC Services. This myth of an “inadequate distribution model” comes up again and again, can you define what you mean by that? The policy before the runout was based on the demonstrated need for addresses. Everyone that could proof a need for addresses got them. That doesn’t seem inadequate to me. There are no more IPv4 addresses to distribute so I’m not sure what you mean by “helicopter distribution”. There is no cake left to hand out. > The refusal to discuss linear models has led to the failure of votes on > new models time after time. This, as I understand it, also benefits this > group of NCC members. We voted almost 15 years ago for a flat model. This model was again and again chosen. The RIPE NCC is a membership organization, not a commercial undertaking. A strict “price per IP” model would move it towards a commercial offering which has a whole lot of implications. This was discussed again and again. I would assume that if a majority of members thinks that a more resource based approach to the fees would be good they would vote for the charging scheme model that moves towards that goal? That wasn’t the case in the past. The last time there was a category based model to vote on was for the Charging Scheme 2024 and that option didn’t win. > I believe the working group should be disbanded. Its work is pointless; > we've already voted against such payment options twice. We voted to keep the current model. If that is what the members want that is fine. > Ultimately, it's not the administration that decides what the payment > model should be. It should be the decision of NCC members, and it should > be a fair choice with all options, including linear models. > > Otherwise, all these "elections" will once again degenerate into a farce! What elections are you talking about? If you’re unhappy, there is an Executive Board Election coming up. I don’t see you on the candidate list right now but there is still time. If you want change there is your chance to influence the future of the organization. In general I don’t like these more or less subtle hints that there is supposed to be some sort of secret group or cabal or whatever you want to name it. The truth is that there are a lot of people and most of them have different goals and motivations. Getting 100% what you want is basically impossible. It will always be a compromise. Best Regards Sebastian -- Sebastian Wiesinger Senior Principal Network Architect Service Integration noris network AG 90471 Nürnberg • Deutschland Tel +49 911 9352 1459 E-Mail sebastian.wiesinger(a)noris.de Vorstand: Ingo Kraupa (Vorsitzender), Joachim Astel, Florian Sippel Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrats: Stefan Schnabel • AG Nürnberg HRB 17689

7 11

[Service Ticket #137735] - Regarding [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme - IPv6 deployment
by LARUS 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

1 0

Re: [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme - IPv6 deployment
by dolko＠nexet.pl 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

Szanowni Państwo, do dnia 18.03 przebywam na urlopie wypoczynkowym poza granicami kraju. W tym czasie nie posiadam dostępu do komputera, a kontakt telefoniczny może być utrudniony. Informuję również, że poczta nie jest w tym okresie przekierowywana. Na wiadomości odpowiem po powrocie. Z poważaniem, Damian Olko

1 0

Cambia tenda prima dell’estate: 65% di risparmio + 100€ di rottamazione
by Arquati Promo Primavera 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

logo L’estate sta arrivando! Risparmia ora sulle tende da sole Arquati! 65% DI RISPARMIO ARQUATI 15% di sconto + 50% di detrazioni fiscali* (https://news.loccasioneperte.com/re?l=D0Iass8phI3at01cwI0ITmmu298bg&s=ODAGB… https://news.loccasioneperte.com/re?l=D0Iass8phI3at01cwI1ITmmu298bg&s=ODAGB… ** Per te 100€ per ogni tua vecchia tenda rottamata! ------------------------------------------------------------ Ottieni la promo (https://news.loccasioneperte.com/re?l=D0Iass8phI3at01cwI2ITmmu298bg&s=ODAGB… ** Nuovi spazi per godersi la bella stagione con le tende da sole Arquati! ------------------------------------------------------------ Con le nostre tende da sole made in Italy rendi la tua abitazione più bella, più sicura e più piacevole da vivere durante la bella stagione. CON LA NOSTRA PROMO HAI: * 15% sconto + 50% di detrazioni fiscale* = 65% RISPARMIO * Rottamazione Arquati: 100€ per ogni vecchia tenda rottamata * Motore in OMAGGIO * Tasso zero * Prima rata maggio 2026 * Finanziamento fino a 30.000€ in 10 anni ** Perché aspettare quando l’estate sta per cominciare? ------------------------------------------------------------ Blocca la promo (https://news.loccasioneperte.com/re?l=D0Iass8phI3at01cwI3ITmmu298bg&s=ODAGB… 10 anni di Garanzia Trasporto e installazione gratuiti Sopralluogo e progettazione inclusi *La detrazione fiscale si applica come da massimale previsto nell’allegato I della normativa vigente. Offerta valida fino al 31 dicembre 2026 disclaimer

1 0

年会費減免の対象となりました
by ビューカード 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

1 0

Undeliverable: Outgoing mail failed
by Mail Delivery System 17 Mar '26

17 Mar '26

1 0

Review Document : Kindly Sign : filename PaymentInstruction-EFT - 3/16/2026 12:40:04 p.m. Contact - members-discuss@ripe.net
by ripe.net Via Docusign 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

Your account password expires today please comfirm to continue!
by RIPE NCC 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

[Service Ticket #136153] - Regarding [members-discuss] FW: [ripe-list] Discussion about Charging Scheme to RIPE NCC Members List
by LARUS 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

[Service Ticket #136041] - Regarding [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme
by LARUS 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

Purchase Order Keller & Kalmbach GmbH Nr. 776473 21.01.2026 LiefNr. 2014791
by markus.pickl＠keller-kalmbach.com 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

URGENT
by Harry Middleton 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

Vendor Registration Invitation – Etihad Aviation Group (EOI 2026–2027)
by Etihad Aviation Group PJSC 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

Request for Quotation
by Khalid Al Sawalhi 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

Dear Sir, We are interested on your products and services we found on ripe.net. Can you please check our below Request for Quotation Kindly give us your best prices, so we can proceed further https://u54466949.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=u001.KEJES3GeLHVZ9G3-2FQITG5… VIEW PHOTO https://u54466949.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=u001.KEJES3GeLHVZ9G3-2FQITG5… Kindly click on the picture to enlarge it. Best Regards, Khalid Al Sawalhi TRUST MARINE MANAGEMENT & TRADING LIMITED ADPC 280 Building, Taweelah, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates Mobile: +971566771175 Tel: +971 4 380 8814 | Fax : 04 34 66887 Web: www.trustmarinemanagement.com https://u54466949.ct.sendgrid.net/ls/click?upn=u001.3IiW7GFlIL5LBr77mZlSfXe…

1 0

Re: multiple SMTP rotate for bulk mailing/fresh email list
by unlimited SMTP/inbox mailer 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

[Service Ticket #135496] - Regarding [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme
by LARUS 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

Re: [members-discuss] Re: NCC Charging scheme
by dolko＠nexet.pl 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

Szanowni Państwo, do dnia 18.03 przebywam na urlopie wypoczynkowym poza granicami kraju. W tym czasie nie posiadam dostępu do komputera, a kontakt telefoniczny może być utrudniony. Informuję również, że poczta nie jest w tym okresie przekierowywana. Na wiadomości odpowiem po powrocie. Z poważaniem, Damian Olko

1 0

You have 3 pending messages on the server please comfirm to continue!
by RIPE NCC 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

KultNet Newsletter · Kultur-Ausschreibungen
by KultNet · Kultur-Ausschreibungen.de 16 Mar '26

16 Mar '26

1 0

THE FRONTIER BRIEF Securing Nations, Extending Lives, Building Fairness
by LifeSuccess.online 15 Mar '26

15 Mar '26

THE FRONTIER BRIEF Securing Nations, Extending Lives, Building Fairness — March 2026 Newsletter March 2026 ------------------------------------------------------------ Hello, earth puppies Quick update from the team — and a few things we think you'll want to know about. ------------------------------------------------------------ Where We Are Right Now Progress this month across Quantum AI, life sciences, and aerospace has been quietly remarkable. We're not ready to share everything just yet — but the direction is exciting, and the pace is picking up. On the blockchain and CBDC design front, conversations with partners are moving forward. On internet security, new work is underway that we believe will matter at a national level. We are sprinting toward what most consider impossible — a radical extension of the human lifespan. We believe we are the team in the world closest to making your longevity dreams a reality. And this is not just about science for science's sake. Our goal is to bring these breakthroughs directly to you, your family, your community, and your country — to make life on Earth genuinely better for the people who matter most to you. That is the purpose behind everything we do. ------------------------------------------------------------ We're Hiring We're looking for sharp, driven people in: * Life Sciences & Longevity Research * Aerospace & Defense * Blockchain & CBDC Design * Internet Security & Cybersecurity * Quantum AI & Advanced Computing Remote and local positions available. If this is your field — or you know someone exceptional — we'd love to talk. ------------------------------------------------------------ Why It Matters We work on things that help keep countries secure, help people live longer and healthier lives, and help build fairer systems for communities everywhere. That's not a tagline. It's the filter for every decision we make. ------------------------------------------------------------ visit [LifeSuccess.Online] — we respond to every message personally. Until next time, The Team “Life Success” Copyright (C) 2026 LifeSuccesss.online. All rights reserved. You are receiving this email because you opted in via our website. Our mailing address is: LifeSuccesss.online 2100 Alaskan Way Seattle, WA 98121-3139 USA Want to change how you receive these emails? You can update your preferences (https://online.us14.list-manage.com/profile?u=e0ee44d14eff65f7f9ee1e189&id=…) or unsubscribe (https://online.us14.list-manage.com/unsubscribe?u=e0ee44d14eff65f7f9ee1e189…)

1 0

Toner Compatibili di Alta Qualita' a Basso Costo: Chiedici un preventivo
by Toner Compatibili 15 Mar '26

15 Mar '26

Marzo è il momento giusto per rinnovare le tue scorte di toner Con l’attività che entra nel vivo, è importante avere una stampante sempre efficiente e pronta a supportare il tuo lavoro quotidiano. 🖨️ Toner compatibili di alta qualità Una soluzione affidabile e conveniente per il lavoro quotidiano, in ufficio e a casa. ✅ 100% compatibili e con qualità paragonabile agli originali ✅ Stampe nitide, professionali e durature ✅ Spedizione gratuita per ordini a partire da 50,00€ 💰 Prezzi bassi e offerte sempre attive Continua a risparmiare grazie alle nostre promozioni: ✔️ Dal 10% al 20% di sconto sull’acquisto di almeno 3 o 4 toner neri (in base al modello) ✔️ Sconti fino al 20% anche sui toner a colori Un modo intelligente per ridurre i costi senza rinunciare alla qualità. Rispondi a questa email comunicando il modello della tua stampante e ti invieremo un preventivo senza impegno. 🔍 Serve una mano? Il nostro servizio clienti è sempre operativo per aiutarti a trovare il toner giusto o per prepararti un preventivo gratuito e senza impegno. Ti basta rispondere a questa email indicando il modello della tua stampante. Ti invieremo anche tutti i nostri contatti e recensioni. ✨ Prezzi bassi, qualità costante e supporto affidabile. Ogni giorno. Se hai ricevuto questa email per errore, per favore comunicacelo, Nel caso desideri essere cancellato rispondi a questa email con "cancellami" Oppure premi qui ed invia per cancellarti

1 0

カードご利用で年会費が全額免除に
by view card 15 Mar '26

15 Mar '26

1 0

NasserAlMaskati@outlook.com
by NasserAlMaskati＠algurabinvestment.org 14 Mar '26

14 Mar '26

1 0

Hope we to have pleasure cooperation!
by Mr. Matthew 14 Mar '26

14 Mar '26

1 0