RE: Resent: Allocating a LIR an IP block per use
Yes. That is exactly what I would like to do, but the problem is that I can't receive new allocation from RIPE unless my current is used to its half. What I would like to do is receive a new, large PI for BGP use, so it won't be mixed with my aggregateable /16s. I will be more than happy to hear from RIPE how this can be done. It might be that all I have to do is send a 141 with a remark - FOR BGP CUSTS and that would be it, but I'm not really sure. Regards, --- Yuval Shchory Projects Manager NetVision's Corporate Technical Support Department eMail: syuval@netvision.net.il interFAX: 03-5480255 ---
-----Original Message----- From: Jules D Salter [mailto:jules@vas-net.net] Sent: Sunday, December 05, 1999 2:46 PM To: Yuval Shchory; lir-wg@ripe.net Subject: Re: Resent: Allocating a LIR an IP block per use
Yuval,
You could apply for PI (Provider Independant) address space. But you would still need to fill out a RIPE-141 outlining how you intend to use the address space. The other problem with PI space, is that a lot of the backbones don't like routing it unless you have a fairly large aggregate.
The issues are raised in http://www.ripe.net/docs/ripe-127.html
Joolsie
Yuval Shchory wrote:
Hi all,
We would like to request another IP block from RIPE,
current allocation (which we use for our day-to-day assignments to customers), in order to assign from this block only to customers using BGP. I would not want to assign BGP customers from our regular blocks, as it would create a need to subnet the BGP advertisements on
would like to have a block pre-intended for such fragmentation.
However, as far as I recall RIPE's procedure, one can request another IP allocation only after a certain percentage (50% AFAIR) of his allocation has been assigned.
So - am I the only person thinking this is the correct way to do that? Is it possible to request a block for such usage, regardless of
regardless of our these blocks. We the current
allocation's usage?
Regards,
--- Yuval Shchory Projects Manager NetVision's Corporate Technical Support Department eMail: syuval@netvision.net.il interFAX: 03-5480255 ---
On Sun, 5 Dec 1999, Yuval Shchory wrote:
What I would like to do is receive a new, large PI for BGP use, so it won't be mixed with my aggregateable /16s. I will be more than happy to hear from RIPE how this can be done. It might be that all I have to do is send a 141 with a remark - FOR BGP CUSTS and that would be it, but I'm not really sure.
You will not get your own block. RIPE has some PI address space that they give from. You will have to request RIPE directly, on behalf of your customer. But it has some disadvantages to use PI address space. Read the document that Jules referred to. -- Robert Martin-Legène Hi! I'm a .signature virus! Copy me into your .signature to help me spread!
On Sun, 5 Dec 1999, Yuval Shchory wrote:
Yes. That is exactly what I would like to do, but the problem is that I can't receive new allocation from RIPE unless my current is used to its half.
What I would like to do is receive a new, large PI for BGP use, so it won't be mixed with my aggregateable /16s. I will be more than happy to hear from RIPE how this can be done. It might be that all I have to do is send a 141 with a remark - FOR BGP CUSTS and that would be it, but I'm not really sure.
Hi Yuval, just send ripe-141 status PI and see what happehs ;) But, try to avoide thinking about large PI block, you are going to get as large assignement as your customer really needs. Otherwise they would be proposed to become an LIR. Besides it would be better to give detailed explanation why PI is the only way for your customer in their situation. With respect, Larisa Yurkina --- RIPN Registry center -----
Regards,
--- Yuval Shchory Projects Manager NetVision's Corporate Technical Support Department eMail: syuval@netvision.net.il interFAX: 03-5480255 ---
-----Original Message----- From: Jules D Salter [mailto:jules@vas-net.net] Sent: Sunday, December 05, 1999 2:46 PM To: Yuval Shchory; lir-wg@ripe.net Subject: Re: Resent: Allocating a LIR an IP block per use
Yuval,
You could apply for PI (Provider Independant) address space. But you would still need to fill out a RIPE-141 outlining how you intend to use the address space. The other problem with PI space, is that a lot of the backbones don't like routing it unless you have a fairly large aggregate.
The issues are raised in http://www.ripe.net/docs/ripe-127.html
Joolsie
Yuval Shchory wrote:
Hi all,
We would like to request another IP block from RIPE,
current allocation (which we use for our day-to-day assignments to customers), in order to assign from this block only to customers using BGP. I would not want to assign BGP customers from our regular blocks, as it would create a need to subnet the BGP advertisements on
would like to have a block pre-intended for such fragmentation.
However, as far as I recall RIPE's procedure, one can request another IP allocation only after a certain percentage (50% AFAIR) of his allocation has been assigned.
So - am I the only person thinking this is the correct way to do that? Is it possible to request a block for such usage, regardless of
regardless of our these blocks. We the current
allocation's usage?
Regards,
--- Yuval Shchory Projects Manager NetVision's Corporate Technical Support Department eMail: syuval@netvision.net.il interFAX: 03-5480255 ---
participants (3)
-
Larisa A. Yurkina -
Robert Martin-Legène -
Yuval Shchory