Dear People, Please find enclosed the draft minutes of the IPv6 working-group meeting at RIPE 23. Apparantly due to a misunderstanding these have not been sent out to the list yet. Appologies for the delay in sending these out. Kind regards, Naomi de Bruyn RIPE NCC OD: CNRS / UREC Tx: Bernard Tuy Dt: 23.02.1996 NF: ~/RIPE/Meetgs/IPv6wg.mn St: * DRAFT * IPv6 working group RIPE meeting minutes DRAFT RIPE meeting 23rd Amsterdam, January 30th Chair: Francis Dupont Scribe: Bernard Tuy 1. List of participants Peter Galbavy Demon Internet Ltd. Giles Todd Demon Internet Ltd. Nick Shield UKERNA/JANET Patrick Agren France Telecom Network Service paag@transpac.net Nick Reid Demon Internet Ltd. GeertJan de Groot RIPE NCC geertj@ripe.net Pulak Rakshit Cable online Graca Carvalho FCCN/RCCN Jan Hrdonka EUnet CZ Francis Dupont INRIA Dave Morton ECRC Hans Axen France Telecom Network Service haax@transpac.net Mark Cawley PostGEM cawleym@postgem.infonet.c Bill Cessna IBM Global Network wcessna @ vnet.ibm.com Ivan Communod FTNSNL ivan.communod@ftnsnl.atla Sabine Dolderer DENIC Sabine.Dolderer@nic.de Oliver Doll EUnet Deutschland GmbH od@Germany.EU.net Alfons Friedl SERVICOM afriedl@servicom.es Willi Huber SWITCH huber@switch.ch Christophe Huygens Katholieke Universiteit Leuven Christophe.Huygens@kulnet Avgust Jauk ARNES jauk@arnes.si Johannes 5 Joemann Object Factory GmbH joemann@object-factory.co Bettina Kauth DFN-NOC kauth@rus.uni-stuttgart.d Dusan Keprta EuroTel Bratislava Ltd. keprta@eurotel.sk Rushdul Mannan Xara Networks Ltd rm@xara.net Aidan Mcdonald RTC Carlow mcdonald@rtc-carlow.ie Pavel Mikus EuroTel Bratislava Ltd. mikus@eurotel.sk Vaclav Novak CESNET novakv@aci.cvut.cz Patrick O'Farrell PostGEM ofarrellp@postgem.infonet Serhat Oren IBM Global Network Europe Serhat_Oren@nl.ibm.com= Mariusz Ostrowski NASK mariusz@nask.pl Marc Pichon TRANSPAC pichon@rain.fr Juergen Rauschenbach DFN jrau@dfn.de Paul Rolland Oleane rol@oleane.net Miguel Sanz RedIRIS miguel.sanz@rediris.es Ivan Sedinic HPT - Croatian Post and Teleco ivan.sedinic@tel.hr Frank Slyne Telecom Eireann fslyne@internet.telecom.i Bernard Tuy CNRS / UREC Bernard.Tuy@urec.fr Pavel Vachek CESNET tkpv@earn.cvut.cz Tibor Weis SANET - Slovakia tibor@tuzvo.sk 2. Agenda (drafted during the meeting) . Status of IPv6 standards . Tools already available and implementation . what about experiments running today ? . who has (or plan to have) a testbed ? . AOB 3. Status of IPv6 standards 3.1 RFC (PS): . RFC 1883 IPv6 specifications . RFC 1884 Addressing architecture . RFC 1885 ICMPv6 specifications . RFC 1886 DNS extensions for IPv6 . RFC 1887 IPv6 Address allocation . RFC 1897 Test address allocation About Security in IPv6 (and IPv4 as well) one can refer to : . RFC 1825 Security architecture . RFC 1826 Authentication header . RFC 1827 Encapsulating security payload (ESP) . RFC 1828 MD5 authentication . RFC 1829 ESP DES-CBC transform . RFC 1851 ESP triple DES transform . RFC 1852 SHA authentication 3.2 Internet drafts (some of them...) : . transition mechanisms (draft-ietf-ngtrans-trans-mech-02.txt) . neighbor discovery (draft-ietf-ipngwg-discovery-04.txt) . dynamic host configuration (draft-ietf-dhc-dhcpv6-o3.txt) . IPv6 Stateless Address Autoconfiguration (draft-ietf-addrconf-ipv6-auto-07.txt) . IPv6 over Ethernet Networks (draft-ietf-ipngwg-ethernet-ntwrks-01.txt ) . IPv6 Packets over FDDI Networks (draft-ietf-ipngwg-fddi-ntwrks-01.txt ) . IPv6 over token ring (draft-ietf-ipng-token-ring-01.txt) . IP Version 6 over PPP (draft-ietf-ipngwg-pppext-ipv6cp-00.txt)  . IPv6 Program Interfaces for BSD Systems (draft-ietf-ipngwg-bsd-api-03.txt) !attention! : a new API version is coming up. About IPv6 and ATM relationship, one can refer to the following references: . A Framework for IPv6 over ATM (neighbor discovery) (draft-schulter-ipv6atm-framework-00.txt) . IPv6 and neighbour discovery over ATM (draft-ietf-ipatm-ipv6nd-00.txt ) . Support for Multicast over UNI 3.0/3.1 based ATM networks (MARS) (draft-ietf-ipatm-ipmc-10.txt) . NBMA next hop resolution protocol (NHRP) (draft-ietf-rolc-nhrp-07.txt) ... For more information : http://playground.sun.com/pub/ipng/html/ipng-main.html (1) to participate the current IETF discussions, subscribe to ipng@sunroof.eng.sun.com 4. Tools and implementations 4.1 Tools already available: . tcpdump | > decode IPv6 packets . snoop (Solaris) | . BIND patches to support AAAA RR's 4.2 Implementations running: For complete information refer to URL (1) above. 4.2.1 Implementations for hosts with source code available : . INRIA (F. Dupont) NetBSD + FreeBSD available from ftp.inria.fr/network/ipv6 . NRL (R. Atkinson) 4.4 BSD Lite + BSD OS available from ftp.ripe.net 4.2.2 Implementations for hosts with binary code : . Solaris 2.5 version 3 . Digital / Unix version 3.2c . many others are available yet but less information is known about their functionalities : Helwett Packard / UX (SICS, Sweden) BULL (France) FTP Software ... 4.2.3 Implementations for routers . Bay Networks . Cisco Systems . Penril . Telebit (Denmark) ... 5. Testbeds (running or planned): . University of New Hampshire: interoperability experiments see Connectathon meeting (Feb. 5th to 9th) . Grenoble and Rocquencourt (France) interoperability FreeBSD / NetBSD / Solaris implementation tests of INRIA source code tunneling over IPv4 WAN (Renater) . University of Muenster (Germany) DFN and UNI-C tests with 3 Telebit routers . MITRE (= US ISP) 6. AOB: . 2 suggestions came from the audience, to have - the same Agenda at the Berlin RIPE meeting - one hour tutorial on a major IPv6 protocol (ND, ...) and on transition mechanisms at the same meeting. . status of the IPv6 working group: a consensus has been reached at this stage of knowledge of most of the attendees, to focus on what's going on about IPv6 standardization process and what is already running. On a later step, we'll consider to move to a more technical group where experiences of participants can be shared. ____ EoF.