Kurt;
GSE is a poor variation of 8+8. GSE is poor because it is an attempt to make ISP operation more complex (that is, less scalable), which has been the tradition of telephone companies to maximize their revenue.
I fail to see what GSE, 8+8 or anything have to do with telephone companies.
You don't have to, either.
Just never mention GSE.
Interesting argumentation. You are aware that there are quite a lot of people who think that this is the only possible way forward?
Huh? Just at the time GSE was proposal, there are a few people who thought so. However, shortly after that, I have never seen anyone actively supporting GSE. Some just mention GSE without understanding its content, but that's all.
Do you have any more substantial arguments against GSE or 8+8, rather than the ones above?
I have no argument against 8+8. Masataka Ohta