Peter, On Thursday, 2012-04-26 15:04:40 +0200, Peter Koch <pk@DENIC.DE> wrote:
http://go6.si/docs/Requirements-for-IPv6-in-ICT-equipment-v.9.pdf
really good and comprehensive list. Two remarks, the weight of which to be determined by the authors:
1) I'm missing RFCs 2671 and 3226 ("Do support EDNS0 and do it right") in the list of requirements for mobile nodes. RFC 3596 is present, though. Usually the former are mandatory but I have no idea what special size considerations might have applied here.
2) Since all other devices are required to support EDNS0 with "large enough" payloads, the requirements list for CPEs should probably contain RFC 5625, so the CPEs do not get in the way of all those compliant gear on both sides.
I think we need to publish the document without these changes. This is a case where "the perfect is the enemy of the good"(*). Regarding future versions or an errata list... my own advice would be to leave EDNS0 RFCs out of this document, since it is intended for IPv6 recommendations not as a general "here are good things to have" document. I admit I'm not sure where such a list would reside. :( -- Shane (*) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good