Arien,
Arien Vijn wrote: This is how I understand your proposed setup: - Connect this DNS server directly to the L2 IXP infrastructure via an 802.1q NIC. - Configure n VLANs on it - one for each peer. - In each VLAN, the server answers DNS queries on a different /64 address. - Each of these /64 belongs to the aggregate of the respective peers. Is this an accurate description?
You got it. I think that behind a router or firewall instead of directly on the L2 fabric would be better, though.
Where is your problem?
Well, *if* my understanding is correct. Then I do see a number of issues.
A number of them, indeed. And half of them, to be resolved, might require major annoyances including but not limited to: extra hardware, tedious or dirty configuration, hacks, and longs evenings swearing at debugging the darn thing. But none that can't be solved, AFAIK; can you be more specific please? I am not saying this a good configuration as there is none today. I'm not even saying this is the best (or the less worst) that would solve your problem short term. The points I am trying to make are: 1. You want to do multihoming without a multihoming protocol. - It can't be a free lunch. - If you want to do it today anyway, what you have is described above and some other methods equally un-satisfactory. 2. Whatever you do over PA is unlikely to be mergeable with any future multihoming solution including short-term ones. Do not build a multihomed infrastructure on PA, it is not going anywhere. In other words: I'm afraid that whatever you can do today is quick and dirty. Try to make it easier on the community and yourself to clean up later. Local messes are easier to clean than global messes. There is no way nobody has found yet that you will get the multihoming solution both RIPE-NCC and AMS-IX need without an allocation. A PA allocation is not a long-term solution. Every multihoming solution that I have seen requires a clean PA space. Every shot someone takes at PA aggregation diminishes the viability of a good multihoming solution. Don't play with that too much or the only multihoming solution you might ever get is a PI swamp. I short: PA is not what you need in the long run. If you don't want to end up in the PI swamp, don't make my job impossible in delivering the local /48 allocation you need. Michel.