RE: [enum-wg] ITU: debate over User-ENUM administration
"Holders of E.164 numbers which want to be listed in DNS should contact the appropriate zone administrator according to
the
policy which is attached to the zone."
BTW, "holders" is IETF speak, ITU speak should is "assignees" Andrzey wrote:
In Poland, only TSP may apply for the ENUM domain names.
-----Original Message----- From: enum-wg-admin@ripe.net [mailto:enum-wg-admin@ripe.net] On Behalf Of Andrzej Bartosiewicz Sent: Wednesday, February 09, 2005 2:05 PM To: 'Alexander Mayrhofer'; enum-wg@ripe.net Cc: 'Niall O'Reilly'; 'Jim Reid' Subject: RE: [enum-wg] ITU: debate over User-ENUM administration
"Holders of E.164 numbers which want to be listed in DNS should contact the appropriate zone administrator according to
policy which is attached to the zone."
One could interpret that as "only holders may apply".
In Poland, only TSP may apply for the ENUM domain names.
E164 number is not the "product" or stand-alone "service", but the
Ok, Poland is infrastructure/carrier ENUM in disguise of User ENUM and therefore a special case ;-) Richard the part of
agreement between TSP and Subscriber.
Andrzej.
Richard, Our Telecommunication Law enumerate the Subscriber rights connected with E.164 numbers. There is nothing about _additional_ rights for Subscribers, for example right for binding the E.164 number assigned by TSP with other identifiers (numbers assigned by another TSP). http://www.mi.gov.pl/prezentacje/jednostki/1/dokumenty/ustawa_ang.pdf Our Law is also compatible with EU Directives. I'm sure that at least EU national Telecommunication Acts are similar to Polish and there is nothing about "broaden" Subscriber rights to the E164 numbers(including full "management" of the Number). Subscriber's Number is not "owned" by the Subscriber, but is the part of the agreement between TSP and Subscriber. Subscriber has no right for using the number in the contradiction to the Telco Law and the agreement between TSP and Subscriber. Our implementation of ENUM is in harmony with Polish Telco' Law. Andrzej.
Andrzey wrote:
In Poland, only TSP may apply for the ENUM domain names.
Ok, Poland is infrastructure/carrier ENUM in disguise of User ENUM and therefore a special case ;-)
Richard
participants (2)
-
Andrzej Bartosiewicz -
Stastny Richard