Re: Re: [enum-wg] ENUM-capable email client?
An E.164 number may can considered as an identifier of some person, different applications can get corresponding address information by ENUM resolving. I also think that for MUA it should firstly turn an E.164 number into an appointed Email address, which is convenient to access destined person and also can be flexible to change when needed, not ENUM as a new fixed Email address like +861062619750@e164.arpa. Wang Feng fengw@cnnic.cn ======= 2005-10-20 14:20:00 =======
Florian Weimer wrote:
* Carsten Schiefner:
My question is: is anyone aware of a similar extension or even built-in function of a mail client, so that an E.164 number would be resolved to an email address?
Shouldn't this be part of the MTA, and not the MUA? After all, it's some kind of mail routing.
IMO the ENUM lookup should be done in the client before sending the Email to the MTA. Because if there is no email address asscoiated with the E.164 phone number, the client can show the problem to the user immediately, wheras the the MTA would have to generate an error message.
regards klaus
Hi, Wang Feng wrote:
An E.164 number may can considered as an identifier of some person, different applications can get corresponding address information by ENUM resolving.
I also think that for MUA it should firstly turn an E.164 number into an appointed Email address, which is convenient to access destined person and also can be flexible to change when needed, not ENUM as a new fixed Email address like +861062619750@e164.arpa.
this was also the way how I understood Carstens questions. Punching in an ENUM and the 'backend' resolves it to an email john@doe.com Kewin
Wang Feng fengw@cnnic.cn
======= 2005-10-20 14:20:00 =======
Florian Weimer wrote:
* Carsten Schiefner:
My question is: is anyone aware of a similar extension or even built-in function of a mail client, so that an E.164 number would be resolved to an email address?
Shouldn't this be part of the MTA, and not the MUA? After all, it's some kind of mail routing.
IMO the ENUM lookup should be done in the client before sending the Email to the MTA. Because if there is no email address asscoiated with the E.164 phone number, the client can show the problem to the user immediately, wheras the the MTA would have to generate an error message.
regards klaus
participants (2)
-
Kewin Stoeckigt -
Wang Feng