May 2007 - enum-wg - mailman.ripe.net

ENUM-AP-53.1: RIPE NCC to examine and report on "strange queries"
by Brett Carr 29 Jun '07

29 Jun '07

At RIPE 54 in Tallinn we commited to providing more detail on the queries prepended with a + in statistics generated last year: In the time period measured (April-November 2006) There were 13797 queries prepended with a + 10081 came from a single source. 2738 came from two further sources. The rest came from 100 different sources. We hope that this level of data satisfies this action point. Regards Brett -- Brett Carr Manager -- DNS Services Group RIPE Network Coordination Centre Amsterdam

3 3

RE: [enum-wg] ENUM status page at enumdata.org
by Antoin Verschuren 24 May '07

24 May '07

1. What is the country and E.164 code? The Netherlands, +31 2. Who is the delegate for the E.164 code? Stichting Enum Nederland Utrechtseweg 310 PO Box 5022 6802 EA Arnhem The Netherlands 3. The status of deployment (notdelegated>applied>delegated/objected>trial>hiatus>production) delegated 4. ENUM Project contact details (telephone, email, web) Tier-1 registry: Stichting Enum Nederland Utrechtseweg 310 PO Box 5022 6802 EA Arnhem The Netherlands Phone: +31 26 3525576 Fax: +31 26 3525577 Web: http://www.enum.nl Email: info(a)enum.nl Public ENUM platform: Starting June 18 2007: Web: http://www.enuminnederland.nl The public platform will discuss and advice the registry about policy. 5. Is a trial being, or going to be, conducted? No 1. What type of numbers are being used in the trial? None 6. Is there work or plans toward full permanent deployment? Yes, end of 2007 1. What type of numbers are to be used in full deployment? Will be advised by the Public ENUM platform. 7. Who is leading the ENUM project? (government, industry working group, etc.) The tier-1 registry is Stichting Enum Nederland The public ENUM platform will be industry working groups, led by ecp.nl and isoc.nl 8. Who operates the ccTLD for that country at present? SIDN Utrechtseweg 310 PO Box 5022 6802 EA Arnhem The Netherlands 9. What type of organisation runs the ccTLD? (state, private, academic, etc.) Not-for-profit 10. What is the ccTLD legal regulation, if any? None 11. Who is the current Tier 1 registry? Stichting Enum Nederland 12. Who is, or will be, the permanent Tier 1 registry? Stichting Enum Nederland 13. How will the Tier 1 registry selection be made? (i.e. decision, license, concession, agreement, public procurement, etc.) Has been done. Agreement with governament after market consultation. 14. How will the method of cost recovery for the Tier 1 registry's operations? TBD 15. Will there be more than one Tier 1 provider for the country? No 16. Will there be ENUM registrars? Yes 17. What will be the ENUM validation technique? Will be advised by the Public ENUM platform. 18. Is there/will there be a special number block for ENUM and/or IP Telephony? Yes, there are 2 numberblocks (+3185 and +3191) for VoIP services. 19. Is there special treatment for unlisted numbers? No, see also 21. 20. Are there any plans for infrastructure ENUM? TBD 21. What is your ENUM WHOIS address? ENUM does not need whois. 22. Please provide the history of ENUM trials, projects etc., if any. 2001-2002 NLEG report (see www.enuminnederland.nl) 2002 Delegation of 1.3.e164.arpa to governament (Ministry Economic Affairs) 2002-2005 No interest from market 2005 VoIP boom, sudden interest 2006 SIDN starts ENUM initiative, founds Stichting ENUM Nederland (ENUM NL) 2006 Market consultation 31-09-2006 Redelegation of 1.3.e164.arpa to Stichting ENUM Nederland 22-03-2007 Governament and ENUM NL sign agreement on terms for tier-1 registry 18-06-2007 ECP and ISOC NL launch Public ENUM platform 23. What are your future plans? (and dates if available) Operational end 2007 24. What is your date estimate on a production ENUM registry launch? See 23. Antoin Verschuren Technical Policy Advisor SIDN Utrechtseweg 310 PO Box 5022 6802 EA Arnhem The Netherlands T +31 26 3525500 F +31 26 3525505 M +31 6 23368970 E antoin.verschuren(a)sidn.nl W http://www.sidn.nl/

1 0

Re: Status info for enumdata.org
by Volker Messemer/Denic 23 May '07

23 May '07

Dear colleagues, here is the update from Germany for the information shown on http://enumdata.org/: 1. What is the country and E.164 code? Germany, +49 2. Who is the delegate for the E.164 code? DENIC eG Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 60329 Frankfurt Germany 3. The status of deployment (notdelegated>applied>delegated/objected>trial>hiatus>production) production 4. ENUM Project contact details (telephone, email, web) DENIC eG Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 60329 Frankfurt Germany Tel: +49 69 27235 0 Email: enum(a)denic.de Web: http://www.denic.de/en/enum 5. Is a trial being, or going to be, conducted? A Trial was conducted from September 2002 to January 2006 6. What type of numbers are being used in the trial? - geographical numbers - mobile numbers - free-phone numbers - personal numbers - national numbers - service numbers 7. Is there work or plans toward full permanent deployment? Full permanent deployment has been launched in January 2006. 8. What type of numbers are to be used in full deployment? In the full deployment, the same number ranges are used as in the trial: - geographical numbers - mobile numbers - free-phone numbers - personal numbers - national numbers - service numbers 9. Who is leading the ENUM project? (government, industry working group, etc.) Industry (DENIC eG) 10. Who operates the ccTLD for that country at present? DENIC eG Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 60329 Frankfurt Germany 11. What type of organisation runs the ccTLD? (state, private, academic, etc.) private 12. What is the ccTLD legal regulation, if any? None 13. Who is the current Tier 1 registry? DENIC eG Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 60329 Frankfurt Germany 14. Who is, or will be, the permanent Tier 1 registry? DENIC eG Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 60329 Frankfurt Germany 15. How will the Tier 1 registry selection be made? (i.e. decision, license, concession, agreement, public procurement, etc.) Initiative of the industry concerned 16. How will the method of cost recovery for the Tier 1 registry's operations? Charging of Domains 17. Will there be more than one Tier 1 provider for the country? No 18. Will there be ENUM registrars? Yes 19. What will be the ENUM validation technique? Various techniques were developed by the registrars during the trial phase and are used now in the production phase. 20. Is there/will there be a special number block for ENUM and/or IP Telephony? The number block for national numbers (+49 32) was intended for VoIP telephony but it is not widely used. 21. Is there special treatment for unlisted numbers? No 22. Are there any plans for infrastructure ENUM? The discussion on infrastructure ENUM has started in Q4 2006. 23. What is your ENUM WHOIS address? http://www.denic.de/en/enum-whois/index.jsp 24. Please provide the history of ENUM trials, projects etc., if any. See http://www.denic.de/en/enum/index.html 25. What are your future plans? (and dates if available) See http://www.denic.de/en/enum/index.html Kind Regards Volker Messemer -- +---------------------------------+--------------------------------+ | Volker Messemer | Tel: +49 69 27235 421 | | DENICoperations | Fax: +49 69 27235 234 | | DENIC eG | E-Mail: messemer(a)denic.de | | Wiesenhüttenplatz 26 | http://www.denic.de | | 60329 Frankfurt am Main | | | DE | | +---------------------------------+--------------------------------+ | Sitz: Frankfurt am Main | | Eingetragen unter Nr. 770 im Genossenschaftsregister beim | | Amtsgericht Frankfurt am Main | | Vorstand: Andreas Bäß, Stephan Deutsch, Marcus Schäfer, | | Carsten Schiefner | | Vorsitzender des Aufsichtsrats: Elmar Knipp | +---------------------------------+--------------------------------+ | PGP-KeyID: 0xDCA306E4 | | Fingerprint: FD9C 7B19 816D 59D6 33FE 2665 10F5 AB5C DCA3 06E4 | +---------------------------------+--------------------------------+

1 0

ENUM status page at enumdata.org
by Carsten Schiefner 22 May '07

22 May '07

Dear ENUM colleagues, I have mentioned it under agenda item C. of the last ENUM WG session (cf. http://www.ripe.net/ripe/meetings/ripe-54/agendas/enum.html) already, but would like to repeat it here: If you represent an ENUM Tier 1 registry or have good contacts to one, please visit - or make them visiting, respectively - http://www.enumdata.org/ to check whether the data for that very registry provided is still correct - or not yet filled in at all. Please send any updates you may have to <enum-wg-chair(a)ripe.net>. Thank you for your cooperation. Best regards, Carsten Schiefner (on behalf of the ENUM WG Co-Chairs)

1 0

RE: [enum-wg] DNSMON for enum zones
by Antoin Verschuren 11 May '07

11 May '07

Jim Reid wrote: > > Wearing my Board hat, I am extremely uncomfortable with the NCC > straying from its core function (running an IP registry) by offering > non-core services that could and should be provided by others. I hope > DNSMON doesn't turn into a repeat of the current layer-9 issues with > DNS hosting at the NCC. Then you're also uncomfortable with RIPE being tier-0 ENUM registry. This keeps popping up. If RIPE offers services outside their IP registry task, it should accomodate for it. Antoin Verschuren Technical Policy Advisor SIDN Utrechtseweg 310 PO Box 5022 680 EA Arnhem The Netherlands T +31 26 3525500 F +31 26 3525505 M +31 6 23368970 E antoin.verschuren(a)sidn.nl W http://www.sidn.nl/

4 6

Radio URL
by Jim Reid 10 May '07

10 May '07

You can listen to an excellent business programme about internet/ telephony convergence at: http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/news/inbusiness/inbusiness_20040930.shtml This is the kind of thing that makes me proud to pay for the BBC. :-)

1 0

52.2 NCC Correspondance Archive
by Patrik Fältström 10 May '07

10 May '07

I did not see the microphone that was the closest to me, so I walked around to find one. When I found one, Carsten had already moved to the next point on the agenda :-) Mea culpa. I just want to have it said that I find the archive extremely valuable. To some degree it is more important for me to have the archive available than in any specific format. I have already tried to get information about some delegation, and have not found it... That said, I rather see one webpage per countrycode, and then one link per "document" than a zip file, archive or whatever. Given all those files exists, one could have a link to a zip file as well. But, most important, make the detailed communication available. "Just do it" Patrik

2 1

DNSMON for enum zones
by Ondřej Surý 09 May '07

09 May '07

Hi, I was trying to RIPE NCC DNSMON service for our 0.2.4.e164.arpa and it was suggested to open this issue on enum-wg, since DNSMON is available only for TLDs according to current policies. I think it would be good idea to change that policy to include ENUM zones as well. Ondrej. -- Ondřej Surý technický ředitel/Chief Technical Officer ----------------------------------------- CZ.NIC, z.s.p.o. -- .cz domain registry Americká 23,120 00 Praha 2,Czech Republic mailto:ondrej.sury@nic.cz http://nic.cz/ sip:ondrej.sury@nic.cz tel:+420.222745110 mob:+420.739013699 fax:+420.222745112 -----------------------------------------

4 6

Delegation of +62/2.6.e164.arpa completed
by Carsten Schiefner 07 May '07

07 May '07

Dear colleagues, "There still is a mistake in your email"... This time is has successfully hidden in the subject - my apologies. It is Indonesia/+62/2.6.e164.arpa, not Vietnam/+84/4.8.e164.arpa. Best regards, Carsten Schiefner -------- Original Message -------- Subject: [enum-wg] Delegation of +84/4.8.e164.arpa completed Date: Mon, 07 May 2007 13:07:17 +0300 From: Carsten Schiefner <enumvoipsip.cs(a)schiefner.de> To: enum-wg(a)ripe.net Dear colleagues, the ENUM delegation request for 2.6.e164.arpa - +62 is Indonesia's E.164 CC - was confirmed by ITU-T TSB on 26 Mar 2007. As per 2 May 2007, 2.6.e164.arpa is delegated to ns1.cbn.net.id. [202.158.20.1, 2001:D10:2:53::53] ns2.cbn.net.id. [202.158.40.1, 2001:D10:A:53::53] ns.enum.postel.go.id. [203.119.54.6] ns1.indosat.net.id. [202.155.0.20] 2.6.e164.arpa becomes the 43rd ENUM delegation. Welcome, Indonesia! :-) Best, Carsten Schiefner (RIPE ENUM WG Co-Chair)

1 0

Delegation of +84/4.8.e164.arpa completed
by Carsten Schiefner 07 May '07

07 May '07

Dear colleagues, the ENUM delegation request for 2.6.e164.arpa - +62 is Indonesia's E.164 CC - was confirmed by ITU-T TSB on 26 Mar 2007. As per 2 May 2007, 2.6.e164.arpa is delegated to ns1.cbn.net.id. [202.158.20.1, 2001:D10:2:53::53] ns2.cbn.net.id. [202.158.40.1, 2001:D10:A:53::53] ns.enum.postel.go.id. [203.119.54.6] ns1.indosat.net.id. [202.155.0.20] 2.6.e164.arpa becomes the 43rd ENUM delegation. Welcome, Indonesia! :-) Best, Carsten Schiefner (RIPE ENUM WG Co-Chair)

1 0