in-addr.arpa glue?
domain: 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa descr: RG79-147-28-0 admin-c: RB45695-RIPE tech-c: RB45695-RIPE zone-c: RB45695-RIPE nserver: rip.psg.com nserver: nlns.globnix.net mnt-by: MAINT-RGNET source: RIPE ***Error: No response from nameserver for zone 28.147.in-addr.arpa when trying to fetch glue. ***Error: Not enough data about 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa was found to be able to run tests. not aware of glue in in-addr.arpa zones does it want me to delete the 28.147.in-addr.arpa parent zone first? that seems scary. randy
and if i enable the parent zone Create FAILED: [domain] 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa domain: 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa descr: RG79-147-28-0 admin-c: RB45695-RIPE tech-c: RB45695-RIPE zone-c: RB45695-RIPE nserver: rip.psg.com nserver: nlns.globnix.net mnt-by: MAINT-RGNET source: RIPE ***Error: Existing less specific domain object found 147.28.0.0/16 randy
Hi, On Thu, Oct 22, 2020 at 06:46:17PM -0700, Randy Bush via db-wg wrote:
domain: 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa descr: RG79-147-28-0 admin-c: RB45695-RIPE tech-c: RB45695-RIPE zone-c: RB45695-RIPE nserver: rip.psg.com nserver: nlns.globnix.net
Maybe this has already been fixed and my reply is "stale" - but taking that risk. From what I can see, the NCC isn't authoritative on the 28.147.in-addr.arpa zone, so trying to add an in-addr arpa object with "nserver:" in it tries to instruct it to do something it can't do - put a delegation in the parent zone. This seems to confuse the tool... Since the parent zone is (now?) running on these servers already, there is no technical need for this domain: object to delegate the 0. subzone. What are you trying to achieve? Gert Doering -- NetMaster -- have you enabled IPv6 on something today...? SpaceNet AG Vorstand: Sebastian v. Bomhard, Michael Emmer Joseph-Dollinger-Bogen 14 Aufsichtsratsvors.: A. Grundner-Culemann D-80807 Muenchen HRB: 136055 (AG Muenchen) Tel: +49 (0)89/32356-444 USt-IdNr.: DE813185279
On 23/10/2020 03:46, Randy Bush via db-wg wrote: Hi Randy,
domain: 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa descr: RG79-147-28-0 admin-c: RB45695-RIPE tech-c: RB45695-RIPE zone-c: RB45695-RIPE nserver: rip.psg.com nserver: nlns.globnix.net mnt-by: MAINT-RGNET source: RIPE
***Error: No response from nameserver for zone 28.147.in-addr.arpa when trying to fetch glue.
***Error: Not enough data about 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa was found to be able to run tests.
I admit that the error message is a bit confusing here. It was emitted by Zonemaster, which we use for pre-delegation testing. It has gotten confused by the presence of the parent zone 28.147.in-addr.arpa. You will not be able to create a domain object for 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa while 28.147.in-addr.arpa exists. You will have to delete the parent domain object first, and then create 0.28.147.in-addr.arpa. Beware! The parent zone (147.in-addr.arpa) is operated by ARIN. The inter-RIR delegation exchange process is quite slow, and it can take several hours for the changes to become visible in the DNS. The worst case scenario can be where the deletion of the 16-sized delegation is picked up by ARIN, but the addition of the /24-sized delegations takes longer, and you face an outage. Regards, Anand Buddhdev RIPE NCC
participants (3)
-
Anand Buddhdev -
Gert Doering -
Randy Bush