Denis, denis walker via db-wg wrote on 03/07/2024 17:33:
The Task Force (TF) made the recommendation in NWI-17, but did not give any justification for it.
the justification is included in the final DB-TF report which was published as ripe-767. The recommendations in the various NWIs should be read in the context of this report.
The high cost and low (if any) benefit of splitting this data is completely pointless. [...]
My recommendation is that we drop NWI-17.
The DB-TF considerations behind NWI-17 related to GDPR, so this wasn't a recommendation that came out of nowhere. It would be a better idea to do something about the recommendation rather than unilaterally dropping it. Since 2021, ML has become a thing. It would be interesting to see if any of the LLMs would return anything useful in response to a query along the lines of "provide a list of all database objects containing information which looks like it's PII". Nick