Daniel, all let me be very clear about one thing: personally, I would also like to see the history of resource allocations. But, there's (on top of the PII Data Protection) the contractual stuff and the AUP. If there's no longer a Service Contract in place and an object is (voluntarily) deleted or the registration is removed by the RIR, then the question may be raised: ° is that information still to be kept and made publicly available? That's the reason why I think we should seek both: - guidance or request by the community, and if requested (or maybe in parallel with the discussion) - a review by the NCC's Legal Department. Wilfried On 2015-05-20 22:32, Daniel Suchy wrote:
Hello, that's good point. But I have another - we still have major parts of RIPE database on FTP - ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/ updated on regular basis.
If someone is smart enough to mirror these (public) data periodically (and anyone can do that), he's also possible to analyse history (with all "deleted" data).
Personal data aren't on FTP already - I think this is enough also for history publishing from RIPE DB history - as data protection is about *personal* data, in my oppinion. Historical data should ommit these pure personal details, but other (technical) history can be published.
With regars, Daniel
On 19.5.2015 12:45, Wilfried Woeber wrote:
The Data Protection environment states that an organisation is not supposed to collect data, or to keep storing it (and even less so, making it publicly accessible!) unless there is a need to do so for the declared reason, operation or goal.
As the obejcts have been deleted, it can be inferred that there is no longer a valid reason to store those items or to make them accessible.