On Mon, 22 Jan 2018 13:48:19 +0000 "Sascha Luck [ml]" <aawg@c4inet.net> wrote:

On Mon, Jan 22, 2018 at 03:42:09PM +0200, ox wrote:

...

I have not seen any objections to the process of emailing a alpha numeric number to abuse-c and then having that number entered into a website (after solving a capcha) This would solve many problems as it would mean that the abuse-c exists and is functional and not an auto-responder or other bot

Did my email somehow not make it to the list? I believe I clearly objected to anything of this sort. And, moreover, the IA clearly states that the NCC has *no* mandate to prescribe to operators how they handle abuse email.

Additionally, the "community" has no mandate to prescribe to the NCC exactly how to implement a policy - this is a contractual matter.

okay, but this is not that. nobody is prescribing to anyone how to handle abuse email. ************************************* this is not an abuse complaint ************************************* it is a verification that abuse-c is a functional email address. do you see the difference? so, still, there has been no objections to the verification process - if you have an objection to the process or would like to contribute an improvement, please do so Sascha? Kind Regards Andre