regarding proposal 2017-02
Dear WG, In response to the announcement made on Fri 29/09/2017 11:58 regarding NEW PROPOSAL: 2017-02, "Regular abuse-c Validation" I would like to bring forward for your consideration: The proposed new policy text '... In cases where the "abuse-mailbox:" contact attribute is invalid, the RIPE NCC will follow up with the resource holder and attempt to correct the issue.' implies that RIPE NCC will attempt to correct the issue. Consider "In cases where the "abuse-mailbox:" contact attribute is [add: marked as] invalid, the RIPE NCC will follow up with the resource holder and [remove: attempt] [add: require him] to correct the issue." Furthermore: Since you are stating in the rationale "If organisations are not cooperative, the RIPE NCC ultimately has the possibility to close their RIPE NCC membership and deregister their Internet number resources". This ultimate possibility is not described in the current policy (ripe-563) and maybe part of the overarching agreements. Do the overarching agreements contain notification standards and timelines? If not, do these need to be incorporated in the amended ripe-563? My 2 cents. Met vriendelijke groet, Kind regards, Jasper Rappard Performance Consultant Online businesscard https://visitekaartjes.rabobank.nl/Jasper.Rappard ====================================================== Rabobank disclaimer: http://www.rabobank.nl/disclaimer
Hi Jasper,
Furthermore: Since you are stating in the rationale “If organisations are not cooperative, the RIPE NCC ultimately has the possibility to close their RIPE NCC membership and deregister their Internet number resources”. This ultimate possibility is not described in the current policy (ripe-563) and maybe part of the overarching agreements. Do the overarching agreements contain notification standards and timelines? If not, do these need to be incorporated in the amended ripe-563?
That would be https://www.ripe.net/publications/docs/ripe-676: "Closure of Members, Deregistration of Internet Resources and Legacy Internet Resources". A short summary by a non-legal person (me): Violating a policy would be covered under "1.2.1. Termination with a Three-Month Notice Period" which includes "1.2.1.1 Violation of RIPE Policies and RIPE NCC Procedures". The procedure includes sending an email to the registered contacts every 30 days until the problem has been resolved. If it hasn't been resolved after 60 days a postal notification is also sent. If it hasn't been resolved after 90 days the LIR is closed. Cheers, Sander
participants (2)
-
Jasper.Rappard＠rabobank.nl -
Sander Steffann