On Thu, Jul 04, 2013 at 09:53:31PM +0200, Frank Gadegast wrote:
So, does anybody knows any reason how the NCC could revoke an assignment or even an allocation, if there is a technical need and all contract data and RIPE entries are conform to the current regulations ?
TTBOMK, as long as policy requirements are fulfilled there is no mandate to revoke resources. Even if a LIR is closed for being on an embargo list, as happened recently, the resources were transferred to another, unaffected, LIR.
There SHOULD be a possibility how the NCC could revoke assignments, if they are used for obvious abuse.
You are, of course free to initiate a policy proposal to that effect. I don't think there is much political will in the community to give the NCC a mandate to police content, however.
Sounds like to me, if an owner of a house is renting the appartments in his house to criminals, wich build bombs, plan bank robberies and train terrorists and he has no way to terminate or restrict the contract as long as the criminals pay the rent and empty the letterbox ... (sorry for the harsh example, but I think it somehow fits).
I propose that the use of "terrorist" in any argument renders this argument invalid immediately. You may call it "Luck's Law" if it hasn't got a name yet... rgds, Sascha Luck