Dear Colleagues,
I am not a fan of handing out everyone who implements 6RD a /28 or even larger allocation, but we should not hamper the rollout of v6 with this issue! Being this discussion a private one between RIPE-NCC and Swisscom or not, the IPRA explicitly asked Swisscom to take this topic to the community, so they have to bear with the question of whether it is fair to assign a /26 to free.fr and decline a /28 to Swisscom -> for the same implementation <-
The size of all allocations that we make is based on the information that the LIR supplies during the evaluation process and the IPv6 Address Policy. The details of the information that our members supply to us during the evaluation of their requests are confidential and therefore we cannot disclose these. We do ensure that all our members and their requests are treated in an impartial and fair way.
Was the address policy a different one at the time free.fr got their prefix?
There have been several changes to the address policies since Free.fr received their allocation, but their request would not result in a different size block today. Best regards, Alex Le Heux RIPE NCC