Hi Gert, Gert Doering wrote:
On Mon, Dec 05, 2005 at 07:14:33PM +0100, Carsten Schiefner wrote:
Also, such a policy is most likely in direct conflict with one of the basic paradigms of a RIR - which is equal treatment of its members in equal circumstances.
Circumstances before and after reaching a given number of routes are not "equal".
where _eaxctly!_ sits the difference between LIR #5000 and LIR #5001 - to pick up your example? And why is '5,000' _not!_ totally arbitrary? Although I am mostly agnostic wrt. the general discussion here so far, I am absolutely in line with Andre Oppermann's comment that we better have profound and sound answers to those questions ready before such a policy would be put in place - because they would be asked the second after anyways, most likely by these well-known, interested third parties... Best, Carsten