* Sander Steffann
It is again a balance of address policy vs routing table conservation. I personally wouldn't have a problem with letting an LIR keep their PI space when they get their PA space. How does this working group feel about that?
Me neither. I think is fine to *encourage* newly formed LIRs to return IPv6 PI when they're requesting PA, but *requiring* it is a tad too tough. If the end result is that the newly formed LIRs cannot provision their End Users with IPv6 addresses because they cannot realistically get PA space, we're doing something wrong... That said, this isn't my itch to scratch really (I already have all the IPv6 I need)...so if you want to do a proposal, Richard, go right ahead! I promised myself 2014 would be a proposal-free year...and besides I won't be going to Warszawa either. :-/ Tore