Domain names require a) a contract, and b) a yearly fee (at least for domains under most commercially relevant top-level domains). 2007-01 is actually modelled quite similar to the way the .DE TLD operates.
the at least is important, you have choice : contract or no contract. fees or not fees. 2007-1 limit choice : contract with LIR that has contract with RIPE or contract with Ripe is it the same.
Please re-read the discussions about 2006-01, and 2007-01, and think about what you *really* want - good for you, and good for the Internet as a whole. The end result will always be a compromise, because there is no way to make everybody happy at the same time - but we need to find a compromise that is better than what we currently have (which is *bad*).
yes. the 2007-1 concern internet ressource like AS and PI (not PA). this 2007-1 affect PI. and in a way the 2008-1 (because a lot of inetnum holder do not have contract). well for whole Internet. i do not beleive that the same rule for EVERYBODY MUST FOLLOW is the good/bad choice. what we believe is: to let a little window of freedom/choice. today ipv4-PI holder has this freedom. the compromise is: must have contract relationship become may have contract relationship. bst regards. Frederic
Gert Doering -- APWG chair